- All Delighted People

Sufjan Stevens - All Delighted People
Based on 12 reviews
Based on
42 ratings

Apple Music



That approach does favors to the original version of "All Delighted People" and "Djohariah", self-contained song islands that would have been nearly impossible to include on Sufjan's cohesive albums. "All Delighted People" is a definitive Sufjan song, encompassing all his guises over the span of 11 deceptively brisk minutes: joyous overseer of big-top orchestration and intimate balladeer, preacher and confessor. "All Delighted People" feels capable of peaking at any given moment, which makes it a consistently gripping listen up to its pulled-taut outro of tremolo strings. Oddly, the much shorter re-edit is the one that feels like a chore to get through, largely because the second half enables Stevens' weakness for prickly and aimless short-circuited guitar soloing.


With no fanfare or hype, fans were unable to wait anxiously in hopes of another masterpiece. This was a smart move on Stevens’ part because All Delighted People is a minor letdown, but it could have been a major one had he allowed anticipation to build. Most damning of all is the EP’s title track: an absolute clusterfuck of hubris.

Drowned in Sound

When you’ve captured the hearts of indie boys and girls the world over with ingenious indie-folk paeans to Illinoise, Michigan, swans, life and death, your relationship with God, the Chinese zodiac, the child-like joys of Christmas... when you are the indie darling du jour, when you are Sufjan Stevens, you can do whatever the hell you want.

No Ripcord

The EP is built on and supported by two versions of the title track: the original, clocking in at 11:38, and the classic rock version, which was thinned down to a lean eight minutes. Before I go on, though, I should note that I don't actually immediately hate all songs that lean toward the lengthy end of the spectrum; just look back at my Moulettes review. But my initial distrust and general misunderstanding are perfectly supported and summarized in these aforementioned tracks, along with a song that clocks in at just over 17-minutes

I absolutely love Sufjan Stevens, and this EP is what I would recommend to people if they want to hear exactly what he is about.

Maybe the least experimental record of his, but still incredibly powerful nonetheless. The production is less layered and textured than Illinois, but still manages to sound very pleasing.

Sufjan's songwriting is fantastic here as well.
When does Sufjan Stevens ever not impress me? Looking at the critical reception of this EP, I was expecting some throwaway tracks and demos that didn't make the cut maybe. But All Delighted People contains songs that are so beautiful and in tune with Stevens' style that there is no way they could not be enjoyable. His use of brass instrumentation, and what sounds like a small orchestra, on some tracks is juxtaposed perfectly with the stripped down, bare bone tracks that are only Sufjan and ... read more
Stream-of-consiousness and without pretense, despite the song islands. Not a Sufjan album, most definitely a loose collection of material from the comeback period.
I don't really get all the negative reviews for this EP. I'd consider this one of Sufjan's best work overall. I absolutely love the 10+ minute songs on this album by how they're arranged and just how intense they get. The shorter tracks are all very solid as well with some really moving lyrics and beautiful compositions. It's definitely an EP that shows Sufjan progressing further with the sound used on 'Illinois.'

Favourite tracks: All Delighted People (Original Version), The Owl and the ... read more
More user reviews
Fleet Foxes - Helplessness Blues

Fleet Foxes

Helplessness Blues

Joanna Newsom - Ys

Joanna Newsom


Bright Eyes - I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning

Bright Eyes

I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning

Grizzly Bear - Veckatimest

Grizzly Bear


Joanna Newsom - Have One on Me

Joanna Newsom

Have One on Me

Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago

Bon Iver

For Emma, Forever Ago

The National - Alligator

The National


Radiohead - In Rainbows


In Rainbows