|
John VandersliceWhite Wilderness68 Based on 7 reviews 2011 Ranking: #333 / 498
What do you think? Comments ()
|
It's at once musically challenging, undeniably engaging, and often quite mesmerising.
Vanderslice and Choi have made a memorable album that successfully adds a new twist to Vanderslice's catalog.
The Orchestra’s lively arrangements are mostly quite fascinating, but JV’s exacting pop sensibility and his backing group’s exploratory approach don’t always balance each other out.
The bare bones of his usually excellent songwriting are there, but it’s more constrained by the orchestration than set free.
It's indebted to an over-complication of ideas in a collaboration that struggles to flourish the way it should do on paper.

| 80 | AllMusic |
| 80 | musicOMH |
| 72 | Pitchfork |
| 70 | PopMatters |
| 60 | Tiny Mix Tapes |
| 50 | Drowned in Sound |
| 50 | No Ripcord |