Red Hot Chili Peppers - I'm With You
Critic Score
Based on 29 reviews
2011 Ratings: #785 / 1031
User Score
Based on 541 ratings
2011 Rank: #392
Liked by 31 people
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

70
PopMatters

It’s certainly a far more engaging album than anyone could have reasonably expected.

70
Beats Per Minute

The album is an above average collection for a band well past their expected use-by date.

60
Consequence of Sound

What hurts I’m With You is what has plagued the last few Chili Peppers releases: Kiedis’ vocal tones.

50
The Needle Drop
This band isn't gonna take the changes they face lying down. I like that. Though I'm not in love with every track here, I like that.
50
No Ripcord

Despite the glimmers of hope, I’m With You is mostly just really, really bland.

40
Pitchfork

I'm With You's hip thrusts and gyrations simply go through the motions, the work of a band with all kinds of capital to blow but no incentive to do anything differently.

40
Drowned in Sound

Creatively, this is a band in a terminal, unrecoverable spiral-dive.

MickyT
30

John Frusciante.

Doofy
16

After a more miss than hit double album you'd have been forgiven for perhaps anticipating most long in the tooth bands would hang up their guitars - the Chili Peppers fly in the face of such logic.

No, instead they dug deep and five years later returned with 'I'm With You', a concept album about a fly that fills its days helping people remember which pills they're due to take. What a hero.

Eh, sadly that was a fabrication - in reality they returned with a totally forgettable album that also ... read more

TheCarioca
74

Monarchy of Roses - 4/5
Factory of Faith - 3/5
Brendan's Death Song - 5/5 ❤
Ethiopia - 5/5 ❤
Annie Wants a Baby - 4/5
Look Around - 5/5 ❤
The Adventures of Rain Dance Maggie - 5/5 ❤
Did I Let You Know - 3/5
Goodbye Hooray - 3/5
Happiness Loves Company - 3/5
Police Station - 4/5
Even You Brutus? - 3/5
Meet Me at the Corner - 3/5
Dance, Dance, Dance - 2/5

CoingamerAOTY
80

A very weird period for the band. It simultaneously has some of their most underrated but also forgettable songs of their entire discog. I do not remember a SINGLE note of Happiness Loves Company.

Surprisingly enough I've never been that fond of the big hit of the record, The Adventures Of Rain Dance Maggie. Certainly a good track in my opinion, and one of the most memorable of the LP, but I've always been more about the other 3 singles, especially Brendan's Death Song jesus CHRIST that song ... read more

massiveautist
99

this album has flaws, maybe.
josh klinghoffer vocals make me feel emotions

49

Okay, I think this is the point where they start to go downhill again. I will say, that it's still a heck of a lot easier to deal with an album like this than one like the debut. There is quality here, and even songs I don't like people still seem to like it. I enjoy exactly half of the tracks, yet the quality of them isn't really that mind-blowing for the most part. A bit below mid, a pretty weak album overall. A lot like what I'm sure happened to that fly after they took that photo. I'm so ... read more

Purchasing I'm With You from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?