|
The NationalBoxer87 Based on 10 reviews 2007 Ranking: #6 / 136 MUST HEAR
What do you think? Comments ()
|
What a dross opening verse to a record. Try to spout those sub-Springsteen lines without sounding a prat. Uttered by Matt Berninger’s reassuring croon, though, it seems so vital. Berninger seems the sort of majestic loser that you can associate with, a man ridden with gin-soaked, existential guilt. Under the dreary-eyed malaise of ‘Fake Empire’, The National return. Whilst the triumphant fist that previous LP Alligator rose may have lowered, Boxer documents the standard relationship gripes with absolute resignation and, though not quite as immediately arresting and rampant as its plaudit-acquiring predecessor, is an album of understated brilliance.
Among critics and fans, the National's third album Alligator has become synonymous with the term grower. Released to minor acclaim early in 2005, the album has since quietly and steadily built up a large, avid listenership. Matt Berninger's lyrics-- initially off-putting and seemingly obtuse in their non sequiturs and stray details-- proved unpretentiously poetic over time. His sober baritone and dogged repetition of phrases and passages made it sound like he was trying to figure the songs out in tandem with the listener. The band, meanwhile, played around the hooks instead of hard-selling t hem, so that in a sense, despite two previous albums and a killer EP, we all pretty much learned how to listen to the National on Alligator, eventually finding deeper shades of meanings in the words, sympathizing with Berninger's anxieties, laughing at his grim jokes, and tapping out the band's complex rhythms on desktops and steering wheels.
| 100 | A.V. Club |
| 100 | musicOMH |
| 90 | Drowned in Sound |
| 90 | No Ripcord |
| 90 | PopMatters |
| 86 | Pitchfork |
| 80 | AllMusic |
| 80 | Spin |
| 70 | NME |
| 60 | Paste |
| # 2 - | A.V. Club |
| # 12 - | Drowned in Sound |
| # 17 - | Pitchfork |
| # 110 - | Pitchfork |