Your Review

CRITIC REVIEWS

100
The Skinny

Pure Comedy is the perfect name for an album like this; one that trades in seemingly serious evocations, but ultimately reveals itself to be a farce. After 74 minutes of self-congratulatory back-slapping, proselytising, hand-wringing and relativising, Tillman reinforces his belief in man's ineffectuality and weakness amid cosmic indifference.

100
Pretty Much Amazing

A handful of superb records have already been released in 2017. Pure Comedy’s scope, ambition, and beauty herald something bigger: the year’s first great album.

100
NME

Father John Misty’s third album is a beautiful, illuminating masterpiece ... Musically, we’re on pretty familiar territory; a little soulful Jackson Browne, a smidge of acoustic Neil Young and even a touch of piano-tinkling Elton John, as well as a gospel choir thrown into the mix, but this is a record that sets itself apart by virtue of its lyrics.

100
The Guardian

A great deal of the album’s power comes from the way the bleakness of the lyrics is offset by the lusciousness of the melodies and the comforting familiarity of the sound, with its acoustic guitars and beautifully subtle orchestrations.

100
Mojo

Pure Comedy is quite a leap, both lyrically, in being an extended treatise on what it means to be human in 2017 and musically

92
Paste

Pure Comedy lives up to its title. It’s a comedy in every sense of the word. Absurdity is the order of the day. There are jokes around every turn. The central joke being the perfectly dissonant balance of sincerity and sarcasm conveyed by music and lyrics alike.

90
Slant Magazine

Eschewing I Love You, Honeybear's genre-hopping eclecticism, Pure Comedy's understated arrangements of barebones piano and acoustic guitar ensure the focus remains squarely on Tillman's lyrics and captivating voice.

90
Exclaim!

Pure Comedy is packed with so much meaning and complexity, it feels as overwhelmingly absurd, joyous, curious, tragic, extraordinary and contradictory as life itself.

90
Under The Radar

Pure Comedy raises the stakes, moving from an already ambitious personal concept album to a wider exploration of what it means to be human. His trademark lyrics remain; full of intimate observation and wry humor, but the scope has blown out of all proportion. In lesser hands it could have become unwieldy and pretentious. Tillman is simply too good for that.

90
PopMatters

Joshua Tillman has crafted one of the year’s most undoubtedly ambitious albums, melding of-the-moment musings with classicist songwriting. It’s his best work yet.

90
The Needle Drop

Father John Misty delivers an ambitious and grand statement on the human condition with Pure Comedy, one of 2017's most necessary albums.

84
GIGsoup

It’s a record that is by turns wonderful and frustrating – but for all its ups and downs, one thing remains clear: Josh Tillman has ascended to a new level of songcraft with ‘Pure Comedy’.

83
Consequence of Sound

Misty’s new album, Pure Comedy, meditates on, and makes the case for, life not being some whimsical comedy of errors, but a tragedy so unbelievable you can’t help but laugh.

83
Entertainment Weekly

The 75-minute opus is his most boldly experimental and richly produced album to date, with 13 songs that touch on baroque pop, orchestral folk, stark piano balladry, and even gospel.

83
A.V. Club

The attention-grabbing flamboyance of the Father John Misty mystique is lately proving to be inversely proportional to the actual execution of Tillman’s music. Pure Comedy is a placid, undulating folk record with orchestral flourishes—more precisely, a modern update of mellow AM Gold.

80
Drowned in Sound

Despite its multitude of sideways glances, Pure Comedy isn’t a contemptuous sneer, rather an attempt to dust oneself off and seek control of a ship that’s destined to sink no matter what.

80
Loud and Quiet

If ‘I Love You, Honeybear’ was a sarcastic title for a record of hard truths, it’s got nothing on the name ‘Pure Comedy’ – Tillman’s 75-minute slow avalanche of ballads that relentlessly nags at the absurdity of mankind.

80
Clash

Misty keeps this album pretty genuine. There are jaunts and horns and dancing mixed with sorrow and piano and heartache; his lyrics cutting through any joy with wicked humour and his comic persona still second place to his incredible songwriting.

80
American Songwriter

In this era of easily digested ideas made for short attention spans, Father John Misty challenges his audience to stick with him on a rewarding hour and a quarter slo-mo journey to a sphere that may share a few too many comparisons to ours for comfort.

80
The Independent

An absorbing, intermittently amusing album.

80
NOW Magazine

The Tillman of Pure Comedy ... is in full cultural-criticism mode, analyzing politics, celebrity obsession, social media, the environment and the impending doom of humankind. Yes, when stacked next to each other, those themes have a whiff of pretension that will likely rile his detractors. But, after 75 sprawling minutes, Tillman will have fans believing his gospel.

80
AllMusic

From a certain angle, all this can play like an elaborate stunt ... but there's a strong melancholy undercurrent to Pure Comedy that suggests Father John Misty is something more than a jester. All of this can be felt through the music itself ... and that, more than the verbal gymnastics, is why Pure Comedy delivers upon much of Father John Misty's outlandish promises.

80
Rolling Stone

What makes this more than glib is a golden-era songwriting craft evidently shaped by Tillman's tenure with Fleet Foxes, and his unsparing self-examination.

80
DIY

‘Pure Comedy’ needs investment. It’s verbose and it aims high and it’s not a record you can stick on in the background while you play Candy Crush. But unplug from this modern game of life just for a little while and it’s a very, very special reward indeed.

80
Uncut

For Tillman, Pure Comedy represents a deepening of his artistry, and perhaps, a reaction to the hollowness, the absurdity of success.

80
Northern Transmissions

There’s something immediately classic about “Pure Comedy” in its mixing of Elton John meets talking about mundane life, with the booming compositional moments to boot.

76
Pitchfork

Beneath Pure Comedy’s synth-dappled country, blue-eyed soul, and pop fashioned after George Harrison is a battleground filled with religion, pop culture, technology, and neoliberalism.

75
The Line of Best Fit

He may only be another album (and/or a few tweets) away from becoming a parody of himself, but for now Pure Comedy is another elongated and extensive example of Misty’s intense outlook on cliché, contradictory and conceived contemporary life.

62
Sputnikmusic

Pure Comedy shoots itself in the foot too many times to become the masterpiece it longs to be, but as a singular document of its creator’s remarkably incisive wit, deep well of pathos, and thorough eye for detail, it’s hard not to fall just a little bit in love with it. Even if you never listen to it again.

60
musicOMH

It’s just a shame that this only partly inspired slog isn’t a little more, well, entertaining.

60
The 405

Misty's seemingly constant performance art, the artist as satire, has always threatened to overshadow his actual music, but here it seems whatever humanity Honeybear reeked of has been cloaked in ten layers of defensive discomfort.

40
No Ripcord

One of the most frustrating releases of recent times. Tracks meander insipidly, crushed by the weight of a solipsistic “message” and the real moments of quality only serve as a reminder of what might have been.

30
God Is in the TV

There’s no variety, no upbeat numbers, no peaks or troughs, not even any virtuoso musicianship to briefly capture the attention. Just 72 minutes of blandness, with Tillman’s verbal diarrhoea smeared all over it.

Mar 12, 2017
20
This album is fucking awful, what is wrong with you people
Apr 7, 2017
FearFlour
85
Pure Comedy is Tillman's third and most ambitious album yet. This album is a slight change of pace from his other two albums, in that the more romantic themes displayed on Fear Fun and especially I Love You, Honeybear are not present here. Present, however, is all the cynicism and sarcasm that FJM fans have grown accustomed to. Pure Comedy seems to be somewhat centered around a bleak projection of the future where mankind has let the vulnerabilities of the present time take full force.

The ... read more
Apr 6, 2017*
BuffaloStaple
35
EDIT 2: Ahh fuck I listened to it again and it got even more boring.

EDIT: So I just gave this another listen and it dragged on damn near to the point of unlistenability. This is not a bad album, but it just does not lend itself to repeated listens AT ALL. I recommend just listening to it once while reading along with the lyrics and then just leaving it there. All the shit from my original review still applies though, none of the points made below have changed necessarily, but it's the ... read more
Mar 7, 2017*
dearsongs
91
edit on sept 28:
Still listen to this on a regular basis. There are a couple songs I typically skip but all in all I think this album is amazing and probably my 'favorite' of the decade. I've had mini obsessions with like 10 or so songs on this album. Seeing him during the Pure Comedy tour only solidified my opinion about this album, somehow these songs live might be even better (with the huge arrangement of the PC tour). This album has also lead me to appreciate his 2 previous albums way way ... read more
Apr 5, 2017
95
I don't get why I love this pretentious dick, but I can't stop listening to this album. I'll keep drinking the kool-aid as long as he keeps serving it up.
END OF YEAR LISTS
#13/Uncut
#23/Rough Trade
#48/MOJO
#89/Piccadilly Records
Track List
  1. Pure Comedy
  2. Total Entertainment Forever
  3. Things It Would Have Been Helpful to Know Before the Revolution
  4. Ballad of the Dying Man
  5. Birdie
  6. Leaving LA
  7. A Bigger Paper Bag
  8. When the God of Love Returns There'll Be Hell to Pay
  9. Smoochie
  10. Two Wildly Different Perspectives
  11. The Memo
  12. So I'm Growing Old on Magic Mountain
  13. In Twenty Years or So


Added on: January 23, 2017