|
|
|
ShearwaterRook75 Based on 5 reviews 2008 Ranking: #101 / 187
What do you think? |
Since last year's partially re-recorded and re-released Palo Santo, Shearwater have gone out of their way to assert themselves as more than just an Okkervil River side project or one man's solo recordings, but a living, breathing full band. Rook, however, is their first album-length test, one that reaches deeper into their influences and flexes muscles no one knew they had. Singer and principal songwriter Jonathan Meiburg's voice is just one instrument among many that color these ten tracks, which, in one way, is disappointing, as Meiburg is a stunningly expressive singer who could easily carry a record by himself (see: either edition of Palo Santo). Regardless, they're blessed with engineers who sweat and toil over every incidental noise, guests on everything from clarinet to harp, and a drummer named fucking Thor-- all of whom assert themselves on Rook. This is good news for any listener, but perhaps especially for those who favor the more sensitive and baroque strains of indie rock, yet are tired of hearing it soundtrack every stray minute of public radio or primetime TV: Shearwater give "pretty" indie a good name.
| All Music: | 90 | |
| PopMatters: | 90 | |
| musicOMH: | 80 | |
| Pitchfork: | 80 | |
| Tiny Mix Tapes: | 20 |
| # 16 - | Drowned in Sound |
| # 26 - | musicOMH |
| # 7 - | No Ripcord |
| # 43 - | Pitchfork |
| # 35 - | PopMatters |