AOTY 2017
Deer Tick Vol. 2
Deer Tick - Deer Tick Vol. 2
Critic Score
Based on 7 reviews
2017 Ratings: #375 / 648
User Score
Based on 10 ratings
September 15, 2017 / Release Date
LP / Format
Partisan / Label
Tags
Your Review

CRITIC REVIEWS

90
God Is in the TV

Both volumes contain a very neat total of ten songs each, and confirm that Deer Tick have risen gracefully from humble beginnings to become one of the sharpest bands on the block. This is perhaps even their finest hour.

80
Exclaim!

Unpretentious and unpolished, Deer Tick continue to confront the rigours of life with unapologetic candidness on both volumes here.

75
A.V. Club

For all the noticeable gains Deer Tick has made in its songwriting in recent years, Vol. 2 offers sufficient proof that it hasn’t lost its raw nerve.

70
Pitchfork

with Vol. 1 and Vol. 2, McCauley solidifies his status as a modern-day barstool poet.

70
AllMusic

Unlike Vol. 1, which ran out of steam during its last third, Vol. 2 keeps its momentum from beginning to end, clattering and shambling through its 33 minutes without a false step.

67
Consequence of Sound

Vol. 2’s electric tracks display more charmingly self-effacing awareness and introspection than the performative misbehavior of 2011’s album-length lost weekend Divine Providence

Dec 2, 2017
68
Largely unchanged in their decade of existence, Deer Tick fill a niche in the intersection of Americana and indie rock that may at first seem composed of generic parts, but adds up to an ultimately unique sum. Their decision to split up these components of their sound is a bit confusing since it eliminates some of that uniqueness, but to be fair, many people prefer one or the other between acoustic and electric Deer Tick. Both albums hold up, and interestingly, they’re really not that ... read more
Sep 15, 2017
Jer
75
Both this and Vol. 1 work hand in hand. Which ever one is better is up in the air, they both offer different sounds. But the two of them back to back makes a varied and interesting hour or so of music and I'm more than willing to go back to both.

Favorite Songs: Don't Hurt, Jumpstarting, It's A Whale, Tiny Fortunes
Least Favorite: Look How Clean I Am, Want/Needs
Sep 15, 2017
VinylHound83
83
Don't Hurt - 9/10
Jumpstarting - 9/10
Look How Clean I Am - 7/10
It's a Whale - 7/10
Tiny Fortunes - 10/10
Sloppy - 7/10
Wants / Needs - 8/10
S.M.F. - 10/10
Pulse - NOT RATED INSTRUMENTAL
Mr. Nothing Gets Worse - 8/10

Overall Rating: 75 out of 90 = 83%


Added on: September 9, 2017