Sign In to rate and review

They literally took out everything that was fun about the first project, and created some of the most dull music imaginable. The writing is awful, and the music sucks... until it doesnt AND THEN IT STARTS TO GET GOOD... oh Joe Hawley has creative control again... yup... this sucks.


Hm, something feels missing here.

Don’t get me wrong, I am definitely a big fan of this album. I think it is a much more consistent, solidly constructed work than Tally Hall’s previous escapade. But a big reason why it's more consistent is that it feels fairly by-the-numbers, especially compared to what they’d end up doing as Miracle Musical. There’s a lot less experimentation in this one, which means that while there’s a whole lot of quintessential Tally Hall ... read more


fuck consequence of sound


This one's a grower for sure, but it's way better than Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum. I like this album far more than I can justify. It's just consistently good. I'd say it has less 'highs' than Marvin's, but the lows are so much more bearable and still decent, whereas Marvin's lows are actually awful. At worst a couple of the songs on this album are just a bit mid, but can be enjoyed nonetheless.

I'd prefer this album to Marvin's anyway, because while Marvin's can be charming, I'm ... read more


I think this is a WAY better album than Marvins and it definitely is more solid and consistent.
For me at least there isn't much filler or even skips, I just think sometimes the instrumentation and lyrics can be a bit odd.
Solid record, and I will stand by it.


unlike mmmm this is just boring but at least it doesnt piss me off

Purchasing Good & Evil from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Contributions By
owcs, Pazuzu, CLJesse
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.

Track List

  1. Never Meant to Know
  2. &
  3. You & Me
  4. Cannibal
  5. Who You Are
  6. Sacred Beast
  7. Hymn for a Scarecrow
  8. A Lady
  9. The Trap
  10. Turn the Lights Off
  11. Misery Fell
  12. Out in the Twilight
  13. You
  14. Fate of the Stars
Sign in to comment

Added on: February 16, 2018