Ty Segall & White Fence - Joy
Critic Score
Based on 17 reviews
2018 Ratings: #415 / 464
User Score
Based on 55 ratings
2018 Ratings: #323
July 20, 2018 / Release Date
LP / Format
Drag City / Label
Suggest a Genre
Add
Abuse of this feature may prevent future contributions from your account.
Tags
Your Review

CRITIC REVIEWS

80
Loud and Quiet

For all its picking apart of rock’s history, there’s a peculiar newness to their music, and that’s a very rare thing when rock really is kind of dead.

80
The Guardian
Unsurprisingly, their second joint venture has the white-knuckle ride aspect you’d expect from musicians who produce new music seemingly at will.
78
Paste
With track times mostly clocking in under 120 seconds, it’s a series of quick hits that are warped but relentlessly tuneful, like a Beatles LP that’s spent a blazing hot afternoon lying on a busy freeway.
78
Pitchfork

Joy is an album to be combed through and prodded. It’s a testament to their shorthand with each other, which somehow ties all the fraying, crusty, silken, wiener dog, kitty cat threads so seamlessly together.

75
Northern Transmissions

Going for a concept record akin to a very demented take on The Who’s Tommy, Joy has tons of over-arching energy to it that makes it a really consistent and engaging listen. With this in mind, it’s the eccentricities of both Segall and White Fence that will decide whether you find this album testing as a listener or one of your favourites of the year.

70
AllMusic
A few judicious cuts here and there and it would have been a very strong extended play instead of an uneven album that doesn't quite reach the level the duo attained on Hair. It's still worth checking out for fans either artist though, especially if their eccentric natures are their main attraction.
70
Clash

‘Joy’ is like a rickety wooden rollercoaster – there are a few nice inclines with some mildly disappointing drops between some pulsating flats, and you end up getting off slightly begrudgingly.

65
Under The Radar

Joy is a little tongue-in-cheek at times, but fans of these two should expect nothing less than lo-fi garage at its most controlled and singular.

60
The Skinny

The new collaboration from the foremost disseminators of psych and garage rock is breezy and fun, but also slight and sadly filled with less exciting ideas than their previous joint project.

60
Crack Magazine

Sometimes the jam sesh lacks drive, but even if Joy isn’t the most essential record in either artist’s deep discography, it’s a gratifying testimony to capturing a moment when it feels right.

60
The Observer

Overall ... Joy fails to replicate the shock of the new and for all its effulgent harmonies, a certain gnarly swagger has been lost.

60
DIY

Like any Ty Segall or White Fence record, there is much to savour here, and plenty to pass on as well.

58
A.V. Club

Like a lot of the aggressively trippy ’60s folk Joy hearkens back to, the experimentation yields mixed results.

58
GIGsoup

Ty and Tim pen some juicily different rock here and there, but it’s missing the vital ingredients that tend to make psychedelic rock memorable – it’s the psychedelic without the sizzle.

50
Consequence of Sound

Though it’s sprinkled with promising ideas ... it spends most of its time in a fuzz haze of undercooked hooks and scattershot callbacks that never really lead to any actual cohesion.

50
Spectrum Culture

Joy sounds more like a between-projects sort of toss-off rather than the solid record they could have made.

40
NME
Sure, it’s worth making the effort if you’re already a Segall Stan or a White Fence mega fan, but beyond that? There’s little here to latch onto that’ll make your stay worthwhile.
Jul 20, 2018
chunderz
79
There isn't too much that these two can do wrong, but 'Joy' certainly doesn't reach the same heights as their 2012 effort, 'Hair.'

Ty Segall and Tim Presley opt for significantly shorter tracks throughout the duration of the fifteen-track album, with the only real outlier clocking in at just over 5 minutes. While their trademark sixties-inspired psych-rock nostalgia is still there, they do delve into other eras and genres of rock at times, which makes for a rich listening journey. Lead single ... read more
Jul 23, 2018
78
Going into this album after just how genuinely brilliant “Hair” was many years ago, there were some pretty high standards. But if we’re being real here, my friends this album is a completely different beast. “Hair” was a master class in throwback Rock sounds, with Ty’s Psych Rock mastery and Tim’s expert production creating a high point in both men’s discography's. On the other hand, “Joy” is an often freakish, puzzling and ... read more
Jul 19, 2018
davecoop18
77
Hair = Ty
Joy = Tim

Favorite Tracks: Body Behavior, My Friend, Please Don't Leave This Town, Good Boy, She Is Gold
Jul 25, 2018
joshmq71
47
Wow, this is quite the head scratcher of a record. I'm a fan of Ty Segall's work on the whole and his prior collaboration with Tim Presley "White Hair" is a highlight within both of their discographies, but I found this record woefully dry and underdone. Whilst both artists have worked with short track lengths in the past, the decision to go for these brief song fragments on this record is not at all justified. Each moment just feels unfinished and not in a way where having all of ... read more
Jul 23, 2018
Music_Observer
67
Even without knowing any backstory, one can easily surmise that there are two distinct songwriting styles at work in this short album, being very much a collaboration by two different minded musicians. One style revolved heavily on finding colorful harmonic progression, which was undoubtedly Segall’s side of things. When that side was featured, as in the first five tracks, it was quite successful. The bIII borrowed chord was used especially well throughout the harmonically focused songs ... read more
Purchasing Joy from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Track List
  1. Beginning
  2. Please Don't Leave This Town
  3. Room Connector
  4. Body Behavior
  5. Good Boy
  6. Hey Joel, Where You Going With That?
  7. Rock Flute
  8. A Nod
  9. Grin Without Smile
  10. Other Way
  11. Prettiest Dog
  12. Do Your Hair
  13. She Is Gold
  14. Tommy's Place
  15. My Friend
Contributions By
thisisabtlgrnd, AndreManfre93


Added on: May 14, 2018