Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

100
Highsnobiety
All of his signature hallmarks are still here – the pitch-shifted vocals, the industrialized trip-hop elements – they have simply been cross-pollinated across a rich template of outside influences, giving Rocky the ability to evolve in several directions at once without compromising the record’s cohesion.
83
Consequence of Sound

Testing is loud, frenetic, spastic, and about as vibrant as rap can be. The songs are busy, crowded with radiant instrumentation and stacked vocals, and rarely take time to breathe. It’s a welcome addition to a genre that has become so occupied with spacey, bare-bones operations and overly simplistic results.

80
Spill Magazine

TESTING shows off how talented A$AP Rocky is lyrically as well as behind the scenes being the executive producer for the album. This album is great compliment to how public A$AP Rocky has been in the media recently and is just as interesting. This album has some real staying power with all the guest appearances and incredible talent put into it.

70
Exclaim!

A$AP Rocky has always been a tastemaker with an eclectic palette, and with his third studio album, Testing, he isn't catering to the ears of current hip-hop fans. Rocky is making music outside of the confines of rap while simultaneously pushing boundaries within it.

70
Crack Magazine

While Testing bears all the unapologetic hallmarks of classic Rocky, it's also steeped in an unwillingness to accept the status quo, both in his own work and in the state of the world in 2018.

67
A.V. Club
Though the finished project is as loose and incohesive as its title might suggest, there’s a lot to like about Testing.
67
Pitchfork
Rocky’s anything-goes tests come up short, but they feel like his alone.
64
GIGsoup

Overall, Testing seems to have been too much of a creative reach by ASAP Rocky. It results into a lack luster project torn between rapping and experimenting.

60
AllMusic

While in some ways Testing is more musical than anything we've heard from A$AP Rocky before, it's also more confused, with ideas and musical shifts colliding at times to the point of randomness.

60
The Guardian

Rocky similarly hopped between styles on his two previous albums ... but Testing is a spottier affair. Too many tracks minimise his strengths.

60
NOW Magazine

Testing’s title might suggest experimentation, but it delivers more on tentativeness, with a smattering of solid songs mixed into aesthetically interesting but unresolved experiments.

60
Spectrum Culture

For every bad track on this frustrating album, another one offers a distinctive flair and ability unlike anyone else. But, at least as far as making albums goes, Rocky has yet to take his place in the pantheon of hip-hop royalty. Testing is what it says it is, though this far into his career, he should be doing better than merely a passing grade.

60
The Young Folks

After a three-year wait, Rocky seems to know he’s not as good lyrically as he once was, so he puts all of his efforts into the instrumentals. For better or for worse, the leader of the ASAP Mob shows he can still be great, but also shows he still has some work to do.

58
HipHopDX
Instead of creating a new wave, A$AP Rocky has drowned himself in his own ambitions and lost his identity along the way.
40
The Needle Drop

Testing contains some interesting ideas here and there, but they aren't performed or organized all that well a great deal of the time.

BradTasteMusic
67

I can't be the only one who expected this to suck but was surprised at how solid of a project this was right?

exception
73

Fair amount of straight up filler, but the highs are very high.

fav tracks: A$AP Forever (standout), Fuck Sleep, Praise The Lord, Gunz N Butter

GelatoM0
83

[82.60] This is Rocky's Yeezus. I said it. I know it def doesn't hold that standard, Yeezus being a horny album with surprisingly a lot to unpack and then we have an album, called "TESTING" in which people expected normal sound from him. Like I said in my past review (this prob gon be my final scoring) this album made a comeback compared to when it first came out. I wouldn't say it stood the test of time in general but for sure if you have an attachment to this, in similar fashion to ... read more

Rotten_Carrot
90

very undderrated and overhated album. I understand that opinions differ but without exaggeration

DrRobin
60

some good tracks but this is very generic and boring, especially the second half

Thundrerr
60

favorite: Distorted Records

least favorite: CALLDROPS

Purchasing TESTING from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

Sign in to comment
1mo
1mo
1mo
4mo
5mo


Added on: May 22, 2018