Am I A Girl?

Poppy - Am I A Girl?
Critic Score
Based on 3 reviews
User Score
Based on 380 ratings
2018 Ratings: #824
Liked by 1 person
October 31, 2018 / Release Date
LP / Format
I'm Poppy, Mad Decent / Label
Suggest a Genre
Add
Abuse of this feature may prevent future contributions from your account.
Tags
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

70
The Needle Drop

Poppy and her collaborators have gotten a lot better at working her persona into her music and crafting creative pop songs since last year's Poppy.Computer.

70
AllMusic

While it's not as cohesive as Poppy.Computer, Am I a Girl? definitely isn't stale, and it succeeds at expanding Poppy's sound and identity enough to keep fans listening and guessing.

60
Highsnobiety

Am I a Girl? is an enjoyable enough club record, but it fails to add anything new to the conversation.

oh
76
Am I a oh?
JustSomeGuy
70
Poppy's Am I A Girl? is... a mess of an album to say the least. This album's sound is all over the place, with some songs being exclusively pop, some songs being very heavily rock and metal influenced, and other songs having a mix of all of these genres. Despite this mess of styles which really shouldn't work out as well as it does, Poppy still provides with a fun record that fully succeeds in showing her versatility and proving that she is a pop artist that everybody should look out for.

Just ... read more
WhatTheFunk
63
Poppy's "Am I a Girl?" transcends the limits of the bubblegum bass. In my opinion, bubblegum bass has something very violent and quite frightening. Poppy is well known for her nightmarish miniatures on YouTube, where she jokes openly about the fact that she is a manufactured product, a plastic Barbie, bubblegum that is chewing and spitting. "Am I a Girl?" is a mix of pop styles with futuristic and 80s influences. Poppy successfully transforms stupid catchy songs into ... read more
KnifeTrick
65
edit: originally a 79. this got really stale for me and im not sure why. this record is still solid, but lately most of the song simply just ‘unclick’ed with me.

Is Poppy a girl? That is indeed the question for this record.
This record is quite the handful but enough of it ties up to the Poppy lore and her character as a whole, especially the Interludes, I found those to be intriguing (especially Interlude 2 which sounds like Fitter Happier).

Favs: Time is Up, Aristocrat (the ... read more
MinatoArisato
65
I didn't like this as much as I would have wanted to. I like Poppy for the most part and I think she has a lot of potential but this record is rather messy and just has some weaker moments.

Best Track: In a Minute
Worst Track: Interlude 2
Purchasing Am I A Girl? from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.

Track List

  1. In a Minute
  2. Fashion After All
  3. Iconic
  4. Chic Chick
  5. Interlude 1
  6. Time Is Up (feat. Diplo)
  7. Aristocrat (feat. Garibay)
  8. Hard Feelings
  9. Girls In Bikinis
  10. The Rapture Ball
  11. Interlude 2
  12. Am I a Girl?
  13. Play Destroy (feat. Grimes)
  14. X
Sign in to comment
1y
1y
1y
1y


Added on: September 12, 2018