Ian William Craig - Thresholder
Critic Score
Based on 5 reviews
2018 Ratings: #43 / 716
User Score
Based on 38 ratings
2018 Ratings: #155
November 2, 2018 / Release Date
LP / Format
FatCat / Label
Ambient / Genres
Suggest a Genre
Add
Abuse of this feature may prevent future contributions from your account.
Tags
Your Review

CRITIC REVIEWS

90
Exclaim!

By treating what is essentially a series of sacred music recordings with various techniques designed to degrade those sounds, Craig has delivered an album of church music for an amoral world; spirituals for a broken planet. Awe-inspiring and unforgettable.

90
Spectrum Culture

Easily one of the densest—though also one of the finest—works of his career.

85
The Line of Best Fit

Thresholder is a triumph of meticulously detailed composition and, at the same time, a masterpiece that seems to evolve, albeit in an unnaturally sepulchral soundworld of fragmentation, from the simplest of sources into a life-affirming wholeness.

79
Pitchfork

This compendium of odds and ends from the Canadian singer and sound artist may be his most incisive and convincing album yet, thanks to the way his voice finally becomes one with his machines.

70
AllMusic

While it could be viewed as a clearinghouse of outtakes as Craig works diligently on his next major album, the tracks are sequenced so that they form a coherent whole.

TheRootBoy
78
Ian William Craig constructs an operatic sound building his voice inside the mechanical vibrations. This is contemporary art. The soundtrack of a man-made outer space.
60
Every track of this album:
1. quite distortion
2. building vocals/strings/synthesizers to climax
3. Wall of noise
4. Repeat

Not saying it's bad though, this formula has it's moments. Not really my cup of tea though.
ChrisMan
65
I was expecting to hate this album but I found myself actually getting into it. The constant noise that it bring gives off this hopeful and scarier feeling like you never know what is going to happen. But after the 15 minute mark I started to fell bored with it. But If you have never listened to ambient music before I would give this a try but it’s definitely not for everyone
rika_
60
not too long ago, i probably would have been incredibly bored by this, but as i've grown to enjoy various ambient albums more and more, this one was obviously no exception. with its relatively short length, i never felt like any track was particularly dull, as they all flow together seamlessly and create a beautiful experience. it's not outstanding or anything, but i like it.
Purchasing Thresholder from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

END OF YEAR LISTS

#85/The Quietus

Track List

  1. Elided
  2. Some Absolute Means
  3. TC-377 Poem
  4. Mass Noun
  5. Idea for Contradiction 1
  6. And Therefore the Moonlight
  7. The Last Wesbrook Lament
  8. Discovered in Flat
  9. Sfumato
  10. Idea for Contradiction 2
  11. More Words for Mistake
Sign in to comment
No one has said anything yet.


Added on: October 24, 2018