AOTY 2023

Girl with Basket of Fruit

Xiu Xiu - Girl with Basket of Fruit
Critic Score
Based on 13 reviews
2019 Ratings: #513 / 803
User Score
2019 Ratings: #64
Liked by 270 people
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

90
Tiny Mix Tapes

It’s tempting to say this is Xiu Xiu’s most solid release since their debut, 2002’s Knife Play, but it could be that it just feels more akin than this project has in a while to the acoustic instrumentation and serio-comic histrionic magic of that record.

90
The Needle Drop
Xiu Xiu delivers what might be its most adventurous and harrowing album to date... which is saying a lot.
80
PopMatters

It is this polymorphism of Girl With Basket of Fruits that really shifts Xiu Xiu from their work in Forget, and sees them evolving further.

80
AllMusic

Affecting, cathartic and unsettling, Girl with Basket of Fruit reflects that while the edge to Xiu Xiu's music has changed with time, it never dulls.

80
Sputnikmusic

Words really can't accurately describe what makes Xiu Xiu and Jamie Stewart's writing so timeless no matter the sound or the subject matter, but it never fails to have an emotional power that very few can retain for so long and captivate with ease.

80
Loud and Quiet

Unsettling. That is the first (and kinda only) word that comes to mind just after listening to ‘Girl With Basket of Fruit’.

80
Spill Magazine

Xiu Xiu’s latest album is a difficult listen with a payoff surpassing anything that a review could say.

75
Under the Radar

Stewart's machete may lop off sensitive ears, but here he cuts deep into centuries of unmerited violence, proving that women still have more uphill battles to face.

75
The 405

Girl With A Basket of Fruit is a remarkably bold release, which speaks volumes considering the polarizing nature of this ever-evolving collective. With ricocheting post-industrial energy operating as the musical lifeblood, this album is sadistically cathartic when blasted full-volume.

60
Pitchfork

The duo’s latest speeds between fragmented beats and mournful balladry but rarely makes an impression beyond its sound and fury.

60
FLOOD Magazine

The level of pandemonium and desperation here makes for deeply unsettling but fascinatingly involved listening.

55
Spectrum Culture

On their own, the tracks sound disjointed and lost, but together they do exude a sense of dread and anxiousness difficult to shake off.

35
The Line of Best Fit

Within all its pandemonium, Xiu Xiu’s execution on Girl… feels vapid; it’s as though they’re running on fumes.

BradTasteMusic
100

One of the most unsettling albums ever created.

It is genius?

Edit: this album is very addictive. +3 points for being such an amazing experience I can come back to daily. Early AOTY contender

Edit 2: Issa 10. so a couple months have passed since the release and all I can say is no matter what mood I’m in, or what time of the day it is, If I put on this album I’m blown away. Hopefully I can do a review soon on my channel

fakeplasticrose
73

Yeah I wasn't planning on sleeping tonight anyway

ElectricMess
88

I feel violated

oatz
46

I dont get it

bebe24_7
96

"Really great album which led to me making the decision i will never listen to xiu xiu ever again!!!!!" that was my review for promise and i really wish i stuck to that. this is the most fucked up and disturbing albums ive ever heard that being said its also one of the best. The entire album just feels haunting and hopeless

notatall
100

Girl with Basket of Fruit 10/10
It Comes Out as a Joke 10/10
Amargi ve Moo 8/10
Ice Cream Truck 10/10
Pumpkin Attack on Mommy and Daddy 10/10
The Wrong Thing 9/10
Mary Turner Mary Turner 10/10
Scisssssssors 10/10
Normal Love 9/10

Average: 9.5

Purchasing Girl with Basket of Fruit from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Please stay on topic. To go off topic, head to the General Chat.

Sign in to comment
2mo
4mo
4mo
5mo


Added on: December 6, 2018