Swans - Greed
Critic Score
Based on 1 review
User Score
Based on 251 ratings
1986 Ratings: #37
Liked by 6 people
January 1, 1986 / Release Date
LP / Format
K.422 / Label
Noise Rock, No Wave / Genres / Website
Sign In to rate and review



Greed marks the initial turning point of Swans towards more varied and ultimately even more astonishing musical heights than the early records, which were aggressive beyond all words, ever indicated.

This sounded exactly like Filth, but better. The problem I had with Filth was, the vocal were annoying, he was saying the same stuff half of the time but, I did appreciate the length. And, this album had some of the same problems but, for some reason I enjoyed it. The reason why I gave it such a low score was because, they have much better albums than this. If I only listened to this on its own and didn't listen to anymore Swans albums, it would probably get a 60. And the song Time is Money ... read more
Discography Diaries #2: Swans
Album #3: Greed
Genre: Noise Rock, No Wave
Date: 01/07/2020
Time: 4:10 PM

So now we are on the third studio album from Swans, Greed and with Greed we see a change of pace from them, rather than sticking with the angry, shouty and heavy sound of their previous 2 records, Filth and Cop, we see Michael Gira and co branch out into a more brooding and dreary yet varied sound. Personally I enjoy some of the themes and stylistic attempts on Greed but it falls flat for ... read more
It's dark, it's brooding, it's harsh, but is it enjoyable? Fuck no. Even at 35 minutes, "Greed" just feels like it takes FOREVER to finish. It's so plodding and tedious that it becomes really hard to listen to and not in the right ways. The album's tone is also unbearable, with Michael Gira just going on and on about how he hates his body and wants to crawl in someone else's skin... like, it's not charming or emotional or whatever they were aiming for, it's just yucky.

Straight-up ... read more
This is already leagues better than both previous albums, like holy shit this is a masterpiece compared to what we got before. Greed is Swans' first good album, fight me you know I'm right. I'm honestly surprised to see the mediocre user score, this is a really good album. It takes the industrial sounds from the previous two albums plus the good parts from Cop (Side B basically) and fleshes it out into something great.

This album is huge, it sounds like a huge gaping abyss, asking you to jump ... read more
While some tracks are very monotonous and hard to listen to, this album soundwise is a big step up from Filth and Cop. The tracks are much more different to each other, and they've definitely started expanding on their sound and creating more sinister and intriguing atmospheres. I feel like on some days I'll prefer Filth and on some days I'll prefer this album, even though I think Filth as a full-on project is a bit more structurally enjoyable as an album. Eh, hoping Holy Money will be just as ... read more
Purchasing Greed from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Contributions By
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.

Track List

  1. Fool
  2. AnythingforYou
  3. Nobody
  4. StupidChild
  5. Greed
  6. Heaven
  7. MoneyIsFlesh
Sign in to comment
No one has said anything yet.

Added on: May 12, 2014