Asylum

Critic Score
Based on 8 reviews
2010 Ratings: #738 / 948
User Score
Based on 286 ratings
2010 Ratings: #583
August 31, 2010 / Release Date
LP / Format
Reprise / Label
Disturbed, U2, BonoWriter
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

80
AllMusic
What really sets Disturbed apart from other 21st century metal acts is their ability to consistently repackage and resell their sound in a way that avoids redundancy.
70
PopMatters

If Ten Thousand Fists is the large tiger of Disturbed’s discography, oversized with more muscle than necessary, and Indestructible is the lean jaguar, fine-cut to just the foundation and essentials, then Asylum is the lion, king of the jungle, perfectly balanced in both core strength and added power to create the purest musical engine for emotional expression.

67
Entertainment Weekly

Global warming! Nazis! Werewolves! Disturbed pack their fifth disc Asylum with so much scary stuff it should come with a night-light.

65
Blabbermouth.net
The bottom line about "Asylum" is this, if you were a Disturbed fan yesterday, you'll be one tomorrow. If not, then don't hold your breath in the hopes that this release will finally sell you on them.
60
Classic Rock

Here we have madness, death, betrayal, grief, war and global warming all spewed forth to a churning, battering riff-fest that is impressive in its focus and ferocity ... All of which would be fine in a downbeat and, ahem, mature kind of way were it not for the distinct lack of truly memorable tunes.

30
Sputnikmusic

Disturbed have ... done something here with Asylum that they have never done before: They have made the first album of their discography that can be truly called bad - not good, not average, just wholly bad.

fire21
53

A disappointing follow up to Indestructible

SLT
65

Oh please no more U2.

Although that last track is NOT needed at all (it wasn't even terrible tbh) this was a "decent" album. At least for this band. I didn't really have any favorites, but as much as I heard that this band was awful, I've yet to come across an actually BAD one (besides their debut haha)

notrobinson9
58

Maybe I was just in a better mood but honestly I think this is a significant improvement over Indestructible. The production felt a lot punchier to me and the general songwriting actually isn't half bad. Seems like they actually tried with some of the rifts and choruses on here, and there were a few guitar solos which were nice. But, that doesn't change the fact that this is still Disturbed, meaning the vocals aren't great and the songs are extremely repetitive and blend into ... read more

More popular reviews
notrobinson9
58

Maybe I was just in a better mood but honestly I think this is a significant improvement over Indestructible. The production felt a lot punchier to me and the general songwriting actually isn't half bad. Seems like they actually tried with some of the rifts and choruses on here, and there were a few guitar solos which were nice. But, that doesn't change the fact that this is still Disturbed, meaning the vocals aren't great and the songs are extremely repetitive and blend into ... read more

Metallicafan
50

Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive Repetitive hi.

Now that i have your attention that this album surely did not have, let’s talk about Disturbed’s 2010 record Asylum. This felt SO uninspired to me, it genuinely had the potential to be on the same level as Ten Thousand Fists but nope they had to just record the same fucking song 13 times. Fuck you Davis.

It ... read more

Ticklemaster
90

This is where Disturbed starts getting very same-same with their albums. Some of their worst songs are found on this album, as well as some pretty good ones. Overall it's very good.

More recent reviews
Purchasing Asylum from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1Remnants (Prelude)
2:43
50
2Asylum
4:36
72
3The Infection
4:08
65
4Warrior
3:24
60
5Another Way to Die
4:13
60
6Never Again
3:33
55
7The Animal
4:13
61
8Crucified
4:37
54
9Serpentine
4:09
61
10My Child
3:18
49
11Sacrifice
4:00
55
12Innocence
4:31
55
13ISHFWILF
5:26
Hidden Track
34
Total Length: 52 minutes
Sign in to comment
6d
10mo
11mo

June Playlist