American Beauty / American Psycho

Fall Out Boy - American Beauty / American Psycho
Critic Score
Based on 16 reviews
2015 Ratings: #679 / 1008
User Score
Based on 779 ratings
2015 Ratings: #583
Liked by 33 people
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

100
Entertainment Weekly
Fall Out Boy are clearly concerned with their place in the pantheon. Frontman Patrick Stump expends a lot of his expressive tenor singing about memory and legacy—the kind of conscious legend-building that could be heavy-handed.
90
The Young Folks

Overall, American Beauty/American Psycho is another winner for Fall Out Boy—they manage to mature their sound without losing their signature attitude or feeling.

83
A.V. Club

American Beauty/American Psycho is Fall Out Boy continuing to create its own musical reality—and inviting everyone else to catch up if they can.

80
Alternative Press

Structurally, American Beauty/American Psycho follows the general template of its predecessor, namely towering anthems bolstered by electronic beats, calibrated perfectly for sports arenas around the world.

80
The Guardian

American Beauty/American Psycho ... bristles with nervy ambition, and if it’s not an American Idiot-style career-changer, it’s certainly one of their better releases.

70
AllMusic

The rest of AB/AP is quirkier, a record built on the detritus of the last four decades of consumer culture.

70
Paste
The sonic landscapes have shifted toward a more generic, less dynamic approach—one tailored consciously for 2015 pop radio. But even still, the band’s never sounded more comfortable in its own skin.
70
Exclaim!
Fall Out Boy have honed in on an arena-rattling brand of pop that is different for sure, but likeable nonetheless.
60
DIY
At times the record may not hang together, but it makes up for that in its colour, its audacity, and its unabashed sense of pride at giving just about anything a go.
60
Rolling Stone

When everything connects ... FOB are a glorious nexus of Seventies glitter rock, Eighties radio pop, Nineties R&B and Aughts electro stomp. But the LP still runs the risk of being too cutesy and referential.

60
Spin

It's more ideation than practice, which is why the too-cluttered American Beauty/American Psycho won't be this band's American Idiot.

60
PopMatters

Fall Out Boy take the epic builds and releases of Save Rock and Roll and, against all odds, push that energy even further without collapsing under the weight of their own ambition.

60
Evening Standard

There’s the usual highly strung bluster but American Beauty/American Psycho hurtles by in an appealing blur and they’ve never been more blessed with winning hooks.

60
Kerrang!
It's an often thrilling listen.
45
Spectrum Culture

Two years on from Save Rock and Roll, Fall Out Boy are getting even weirder, splicing their DNA with hip-hop samples and some of the biggest anthems they’ve ever done, but some of the mutations haven’t been pretty.

43
Consequence of Sound

The songwriting on AB/AP isn't exactly dead on arrival, but it's asphyxiated by the band's overzealous urge to sample anything they can get their hands on.

BGL13
75

fuck it this shit slaps

knewnie
55

fuck you i like this album. i find the tunes and choruses super catchy and enjoyable, the instrumentation fun, and the flow of the album is pretty good too. clearly, CLEARLY, a quite flawed album, but ive always had a warm place in my heart for it.

socko
50

the song American Beauty / American sounds like smearing soap in your dick

G_Spyrus
30

Besides "Centuries" which is the mega hit from this album, and it's kinda okay. Anything else in this album ranges from boring to fucking awful. Of all their albums, this has to be the album with the most shitty moments. Songs like "Immortals", "Fourt of July" and "American Beauty/American Psycho" are to me examples of totally unlistenable modern-era Fall Out Boy songs. I love this band so I won't write more about how much I hate this. It's just bad.

BlueStardust
78

I wrote reviews about it, but it ended up not getting saved. So I'll make brief reviews of the individual songs.

Irresistible: 84
American Beauty/American Psycho: 32
Centuries: 94
The Kids Aren't Alright: 83
Uma Thurman: 89
Jetpack Blues: 80
Novocaine: 85
Fourth of July: 48
Favorite Record: 73
Immortals: 82
Twin Skeleton's (Hotel in NYC): 70

Average: 75
Score: 78

51

I get some nostalgia from songs like immortals, centuries and uma Thurman, but that’s it, everything else is painfully boring (thought I kinda like the title track though)

Purchasing American Beauty / American Psycho from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Year End Lists

#7/People
Sign in to comment
6mo
6mo


Added on: November 25, 2014