While the band's subtlety and consistency threaten to work against them at times, XX is still a remarkable debut that rewards repeated listens and leaves listeners wanting more.
The result is sexy like early Portishead and thoughtful like Young Marble Giants—a perfectly formed debut with a genuinely new sound way beyond the sum of identifiable forebears.
They’re not magnificently written, with unspeakably beautiful melodies, and virtuoso instrumental performances, but they have an intangible spook. The XX know when to tense, when to relax.
Throughout its 11 tracks, XX doesn’t so much as demand your devotion as it just slowly and completely takes it. The xx recorded not only the year’s best debut but also one of its best albums, period.
The xx opts for an appealing middle ground between immediacy and ambiance, and the highly sophisticated results are all the more impressive for being delivered by a foursome of 20-year-olds who have somehow acquired a knack for the kind of quietly ambitious songcraft for which some bands strive for their entire careers.
In less than 40 minutes of music, The xx have managed to offer an unforgettable debut and an album that deserves recognition come time for 2009’s year-end lists.
xx is a fantastically innovative album, and this band is exploring new territory.
For a debut album it’s brilliantly realised and contains not an inch of flab across its 11 songs.
Initially hospital-tile sterile, xx rewards volume and repetition like few other albums this year.
The xx’s penchant for concision lends this material some seriously refreshing clarity, but it’d be a mistake to confuse their relative minimalism for some kind of aesthetic singularity.
The band’s resounding achievement ... is to infuse their music with melancholy without letting it lose buoyancy.
xx is a thoroughly cohesive, moving and accessible album. This young band of Londoners exhibits a level of maturity, artistry and potential that far exceeds their years.
They combine sparse melodies, hushed vocal harmonies and haunting production to create one of this year’s most beautiful and original debut albums.
It's an album to play when you're wallowing in a comedown and slow-paced melancholy offers a strange comfort.
As overwrought as the lyrics are, the songs have an attractive, dreamy, atmospheric quality that helps the London band avoid embarrassing teen melancholy.
Listening to The xx’s debut album, it’s impossible not to be overcome by the sort of sublime sadness that feels like a rheumatoid ache in the heart area.
The album will win many friends for its beautifully haunting, understated charms.
Four pouty kids from South London, barely out of their teens, the xx see nothing wrong with playing Timbaland or Jam and Lewis-style R&B with an indie band's chops.
At its heart xx is a pop record, brimming with slow-burning melodies and occasional rousing choruses.
The band isn’t playing catch-up against a nonexistent reputation; they expect the record to speak for itself. And it certainly does. Every song is catchy and immediately enjoyable while not noisy.
It’s strange that such a traditional set-up (drums, bass, keys, guitars, voices) has resulted in one of 2009’s most unique debuts.
The real stand-out factor ... comes in the shape of the sublime vocal partnership between best buds Romy Madley Croft and Oliver Sim who sing up a sultry storm throughout these eleven hugely atmospheric offerings, complimenting each other beautifully and providing a real focal point. Dark and majestic.
While The xx have produced a refreshing, understated debut in a time of super-compressed, post-modern grabs at the attention of the pop consumer, and a record capable of transporting one to a dreamy state of mind, the record doesn’t necessarily have songs.
Honestly was hoping for something a little more groundbreaking in the production, though I do enjoy it a lot. I think Jamie XX has better stuff outside with In Colour but as an indie pop record with a dreamy indietronica atmosphere that is reminiscent of the sound of the 2010s, I enjoy it.
1 | Intro 2:07 | 93 |
2 | VCR 2:57 | 85 |
3 | Crystalised 3:21 | 89 |
4 | Islands 2:40 | 86 |
5 | Heart Skipped a Beat 4:02 | 84 |
6 | Fantasy 2:38 | 76 |
7 | Shelter 4:30 | 81 |
8 | Basic Space 3:08 | 77 |
9 | Infinity 5:13 | 79 |
10 | Night Time 3:36 | 81 |
11 | Stars 4:22 | 78 |
#1 | / | FACT Magazine |
#2 | / | NME |
#3 | / | musicOMH |
#3 | / | Pitchfork |
#4 | / | The Line of Best Fit |
#5 | / | Stereogum |
#5 | / | Treble |
#6 | / | Uncut |
#7 | / | Pretty Much Amazing |
#9 | / | Rolling Stone |