AOTY 2023

"Charlie"

Melt-Banana - "Charlie"
Critic Score
Based on 2 reviews
User Score
Based on 115 ratings
1998 Ratings: #96
Liked by 18 people
October 27, 1998 / Release Date
LP / Format
A-Zap / Label
Noise Rock / Genre
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

50
PopMatters
Remember those old turntables you had as a kid? Sometimes just for kicks youโ€™d play records backwards or play an album at 45 speed. Thatโ€™s the loopy, schizophrenic sound that comes to mind upon listening to the new Melt-Banana record.
50
AllMusic
The schizophrenic sound is stylistically similar to Atari Teenage Riot, the Boredoms, and Ruins, as they frantically assault music as we know it over the course of an album with no apparent purpose other than to excite pure adrenaline and the punk in all of us.
strawberry_AXOL
77

This is how my brain works.

itsyahboinoah
85

I LOVE MELT-BANANA

P.s I did not fucking know Mike Patton was in the track of "Area 877". He killed it!

Fantasio
65

Another stop on my 25 years anniversary trip, and I couldn't avoid this strange one. The Japanese band Melt Banana offers with "Charlie" more noise than music, at least for my listening habits. Fourteen crazed tracks (plus one hidden in the pregap) entertain (or annoy) you for fortunately thirty-five minutes. This kind of music is really not my cup of tea, nevertheless sixty-five points for guts and gumption.

Joedanl
100

Charlie isn't just music, it's an experience. It's explosive, unique, unstoppable, hasty, angry, calm and it's never been done before. You'll be bobbing your head and jumping around for hours.

Nautalcrtzsm64
60

more an exercise in style than a real LP, interesting ideas but the result is a bit fragmented, like a mixed bag. For the noise lovers it might be more compelling

๐ŸŸก๐Ÿ”ด
Fav Track: Introduction for Charlie

80

This album goes HARD. It’s a week later and my face and neck still hurt

Purchasing "Charlie" from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement
Comments (3)

Please stay on topic. To go off topic, head to the General Chat.

Sign in to comment
6mo
6mo
1y


Added on: April 22, 2015