DECENT

Indian indie artist Bodhisattya Pal shows glimpses of great artistic talent in his new EP. Like many artists, however, his EP also shows many signs of growing pains as he experiments with different sounds, languages, and even genres.

While the production and singing could be improved at times, it didn't stop me from appreciating the melodies, lyrics and concept of the album. The concept is an astronomer who has to make a choice between chasing his dreams or finding comfort in stability ... read more

6mo*

Jamobo

Bodhisattya Pal offers up a very interesting EP of several odd sounds that shouldn't work, but kind of do

Astronomer's Dilemma is an eclectic mix of a singer-songwriter guitar and vocals with Trap/Electronic beats with some Hindustani influence thrown in for flavour.

This particular style is most obvious on the first 2 tracks, Threshold Limit and Rocket of Your Dream. It's here that the main problem presents itself though, the mixing. The percussion on these 2 tracks is way to far forward and ... read more

6mo

jkpyg

This is definitely interesting. I think the first 2 tracks are the worst, and I didn’t love to trap beat on it, felt extremely out of place. But Pitch Black Sky is really good and beyond that it’s alright, but something that’s 11 minutes shouldn’t feel like it goes on for half an hour. I’ll come back to this but on first listen I’m not sure how much there is to say about this.

6mo

jules

FAVORITE TRACK: The Last Longing

LEAST FAVORITE TRACK: Rocket of Your Dream

The production on this really just ruins the projects. The vocals aren't my favorite either. I think at times there is promise though in the instrumentals and the lyrics are nice, it's just the vocals are not great.

Sorry man I just really don't like this.

2mo

daFigz™

I do my best to accept invitations from AOTY members to preview a recording. Regardless of the genre, style et al., I give the recording a listen. Often I take notes. Sometimes the music is so distorted I find it intolerable and remove the sound from my room. @BodhisattyaPal invited me to listen to Astronomer's Dilemma and listen I have. Bravo for taking on this creative endeavor. I don't feel you need to apologize for songs sung in a language other than English. While I enjoyed the percussive ... read more

6mo

More user reviews

Purchasing Astronomer's Dilemma from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

More Albums

Contributions By

indranipal

Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.

Track List

Threshold Limit
Rocket of Your Dream
Pitch Black Sky
Had the Spring Arrived There?
The Last Longing
Turning into Cosmic Dust

By Jamobo

By SØREN

By jules

New Bands Made Audible to my intrepid earholios ;-)

By daFigz™

Geo74e longrun for AOTY 2021

By Geo74e

Comments (4)

Sign in to comment

TomBejoy

6mo

@BodhisattyaPal no no no buddy you know theres that indian rapper named nav, i was just saying your one of the only indian people to make music and have it on this site since that hahahah plus I am indian as well