A Different Ship

Here We Go Magic - A Different Ship
Critic Score
Based on 19 reviews
2012 Ratings: #265 / 945
User Score
Based on 17 ratings
May 8, 2012 / Release Date
LP / Format
Secretly Canadian / Label
Experimental / Genres
Suggest a Genre
Add
Abuse of this feature may prevent future contributions from your account.
Tags
Your Review
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

90
musicOMH

A Different Ship might be the sound of a band often cast adrift, but in Godrich there’s now a firm hand on the tiller, his steadying influence streamlining their sound and taking them to the next level.

90
PopMatters

An utterly shattering release that anyone who likes forward-thinking music must have.

81
Paste

A start-to-finish listen, A Different Ship’s tracks dance between one another with a lustrous ease.

80
NME

The Brooklyn-based quintet traverse an unplaceable pop-era on grooves, prog chops and a spellbinding ennui, sounding effortless throughout.

80
Drowned in Sound

The songs on A Different Ship are like Russian dolls – continually shedding one layer of their groove to reveal a different version of the same thing. 

80
No Ripcord

The progression to A Different Ship seems wholly organic, intriguingly complex yet absolutely a true concoction of their folk and experimental elements.

70
Consequence of Sound

Enhancing their previous sound, Godrich allows for an album that shows us the first realization of what Here We Go Magic can be.

70
Under The Radar

It isn't particularly new, or a shocking departure from previous sun-dappled full-length Pigeons, but it is an enjoyable, low-key trip through what they create best: an atmosphere of (dare we say it?) pure magic. 

65
Beats Per Minute

While Ship has a few compelling moments, it’s mostly lethargic and sinks into its own monotonous haze.

63
Pitchfork

Whatever rough edges the band naturally cultivated on their first two albums have been neatly shaved off and sanded down with the help of producer Nigel Godrich, who makes everything sound vacuum-packed and expensive. 

50
A.V. Club

It’s ironic that Godrich fell for the band after witnessing it onstage, since the record he made with Here We Go Magic is a strict studio creation with none of the punch or spontaneity of a great live show.

100
One my favorite albums last year
Purchasing A Different Ship from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

END OF YEAR LISTS

#31/The Fly
#39/Cokemachineglow

Track List

  1. Intro 
  2. Hard to Be Close 
  3. Make Up Your Mind 
  4. Alone but Moving 
  5. I Believe in Action
  6. Over the Ocean 
  7. Made to Be Old
  8. How Do I Know 
  9. Miracle of Mary
  10. A Different Ship
Sign in to comment
No one has said anything yet.
In Library (1)
Bottlekek
Contributions By
patton, erik, philthy


Added on: February 6, 2012