Battle Born

The Killers - Battle Born
Critic Score
Based on 28 reviews
2012 Ratings: #898 / 1098
User Score
Based on 326 ratings
2012 Ratings: #268
Liked by 11 people
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

75
A.V. Club

Instead of being blandly polished, The Killers come off sounding like an excited young band with something to prove.

70
NME

If you’ve the stomach to set aside your indie sensibilities and endure the occasional terrifying flashback to ‘(Everything I Do) I Do It For You’, ‘Battle Born’ holds some majestic moments.

70
Paste

Battle Born forges deeper into their distinctive traits and away from the compromises with radio or current trends

67
Pretty Much Amazing

If you already don’t buy into The Killers, you’ll probably find Battle Born even more bloated, ridiculous, and over-the-top than anything else they’ve ever done.

50
musicOMH

Battle Born is music played in the past tense. Perfect, imperfect, pluperfect. Mostly imperfect.

40
Drowned in Sound

After making it big off the back of a Murder Trilogy, The Killers seem at a loss as to where they’re heading next.

40
Consequence of Sound

The tragedy of Battle Born is that even when it shouts at the top of its lungs, it never reaches that special place that the band accidentally trips into with their best material. 

30
PopMatters

When you add it all up, Battle Born is a confused mess of an album, drenched in influences but positively overextended in its execution, the band trying way too hard to do something grander and more complex than what they’ve done before.

Nightwing734
NR

Ughhhhhh...

First of all, they try to go.. dance.. pop.. rock?? on Day & Age, well that didn't really work out. So on this album...

They try to go full-on Springsteen-style heartland rock, but the execution on most tracks from both albums leave a lot to be desired, unfortunately...

Also, they went heartland rock/alternative rock before on Sam's Town, and that worked out great! what happened here??

Plats
58

"Battle Born" features two of the best Killers songs, "Miss Atomic Bomb" & " Runaways". Unfortunately, the rest of the album repeats the same formula throughout its 51-minute runtime and it relies too much on 80's Heartland nostalgia. Even The Killers don't like this album... yeesh.

Fav Tracks: Miss Atomic Bomb, Runaways, Here With Me, The Way It Was, Battle Born

Least Fav Tracks: Be Still, Heart Of A Girl

Score:
5.8
Okay

KingIsCole10
45

This has to be the lowest point in The Killers discography for me. This album feels like it goes on for so long as the track list is just filled with boring and mediocre tracks. The production and instrumentation is totally generic and the only thing stopping this from being really bad is Flower's energy. The only tracks I enjoyed were Be Still and Battle Born.

Funuf
58

Going into The Killers' fourth studio album, *Battle Born*, I wasn't really sure where to set my expectations. While the band had made a bevy of strong tracks in their first two albums, 2008's *Day & Age* didn't feel as creatively driven. It felt like a lot like *Sam's Town* but with more synthwork incorporated. Now, four years later, I was just kinda hoping that I'd see something a little more unique or something, especially considering how long the break was between these two albums. ... read more

shoegaze_simp
58

Well. They tried to go new wave/dance, and it just didn’t work out as intended. While some of the songs are completely fine, the other ones were just repeating itself while being the worst songs that Brandon & co. ever put out. This killed their career for me, and that definitely was their lowest point. But tbh Wonderful Wonderful was awful as well.

GiorgioMotorola
85

i truly think this album will be reevaluated one day as a misunderstood classic. Or at least a top tier running album.

Purchasing Battle Born from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?


Added on: July 26, 2012