Your Review
Sign In to rate and review
CRITIC REVIEWS
100
Musically, it's arguably even more impressive, showcasing the group's interplay and David Gilmour's solos in particular. And while it's short on actual songs, the long, winding soundscapes are constantly enthralling.
Always had a feeling I wouldn't be crazy about Pink Floyd once I finally gave in and listened to them... Guess I know myself too well.
Original score: 6.5/10
Changed it to 5/10 because I'm petty
...........................
Ok.
I get that this album is important and maybe groundbreaking and deep and all that,
but,
it bored me.
I don't mind it. I just don't see the appeal all that much, especially given how praised this album is. The only part I thought was quite engaging was the title track. The rest are the gentle sleepy sounds.
Changed it to 5/10 because I'm petty
...........................
Ok.
I get that this album is important and maybe groundbreaking and deep and all that,
but,
it bored me.
I don't mind it. I just don't see the appeal all that much, especially given how praised this album is. The only part I thought was quite engaging was the title track. The rest are the gentle sleepy sounds.
This album left me stunned and became one of my favourites very quickly.
The album is amazing musically. The vocals are quite great. Both Gilmour and Waters are wonderful vocalists, especially the former. Also Roy Harper's vocals on "Have a Cigar" are wonderful, no matter what Waters says. The guitar solos on the album are also extraordinary, especially the incredibly soothing one that lasts 8 minutes long, and introduces you the album.
The synths, too, are majestic, like the solo on ... read more
The album is amazing musically. The vocals are quite great. Both Gilmour and Waters are wonderful vocalists, especially the former. Also Roy Harper's vocals on "Have a Cigar" are wonderful, no matter what Waters says. The guitar solos on the album are also extraordinary, especially the incredibly soothing one that lasts 8 minutes long, and introduces you the album.
The synths, too, are majestic, like the solo on ... read more
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
MISC LISTS
| #4 | / | Rolling Stone (Prog Rock) |
| #36 | / | Pitchfork (1970s) |
| #95 | / | Consequence of Sound (All Time) |
| #211 | / | Rolling Stone (All Time) |
Track List
- Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part One) (1-5)
- Welcome To The Machine
- Have A Cigar
- Wish You Were Here
- Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part Two) (6-9)
In Library (189)
Contributions By
alegonzriv youtube.com
Video: Pink Floyd - Take It Back youtube.com
Video: Pink Floyd - Paintbox youtube.com
Video: Pink Floyd - Wot’s… Uh The Deal 
Added on: September 24, 2012
