AOTY 2023

Thank Your Lucky Stars

Beach House - Thank Your Lucky Stars
Critic Score
Based on 22 reviews
2015 Ratings: #370 / 1018
User Score
2015 Ratings: #278
Liked by 84 people
October 16, 2015 / Release Date
LP / Format
Sub Pop / Label
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

90
PopMatters

Thank Your Lucky Stars is melancholy beauty. It’s music for late nights, for falling adrift in slow dark waters and gazing numbly at the glowing moonlight.

85
The Line of Best Fit

Even in the age of instant musical gratification, Beach House could be accused of giving us too much information with such prolificness, but the idea that you can have too much of a good thing is thoroughly debunked with Thank Your Lucky Stars.

83
A.V. Club

It would have been a shame for Thank Your Lucky Stars to have been misspent or glossed over; as is, the full sonic and emotional weight is tremendous.

83
Consequence of Sound

Beach House’s backing music is often the canvas for Legrand to paint her melodic moods, but on Thank Your Lucky Stars, all the pieces work not for each other, but with each other.

82
Northern Transmissions
After so many years of clockwork reliability, it’s refreshing to see Legrand and Scally finally start mixing things up.
81
Pitchfork

These songs feel pneumatic, dusty, like they are pulling a blanket around themselves in a heatless attic to ward off a threatening chill.

80
XS Noize
“Thank Your Lucky Stars” works well with “Depression Cherry” but is a work fully capable of standing on its own.
80
FLOOD Magazine
While “Depression Cherry”‘s churchy psychedelic pop is breezy and somewhat open (as if stained glass windows were propped for sun and shadow), “Thank Your Lucky Stars” closes the shades and shutters the glass for a mustier, darker vibe.
80
Uncut

Coming so soon after Depression Cherry, it would be easy to dismiss Thank Your Lucky Stars as a mere postscript, but, if anything, it’s the more impressive of the pair.

80
SPIN

The material here hews closer to those comfortingly terrestrial recordings than the weightless exercises they’ve indulged in as of late.

80
AllMusic

Interestingly, Thank Your Lucky Stars' more down-to-earth approach allows the duo to cover more musical ground.

75
Under the Radar

Whereas Depression Cherry was filled with sound, dripping with synthy texture and surrounding the listener with guitar leads, Thank Your Lucky Stars is more open and spacious. There's more variation in tempo and instrumentation among the tracks, yet it all flows naturally.

70
Rolling Stone

Thank Your Lucky Stars feels like an opportunity for Beach House to sum up and celebrate the ways they've matured since their self-titled 2006 debut.

70
Clash

'Thank Your Lucky Stars' just barely misses the heights reached a few months before, its more simple nature ensuring it's unable to seduce the heart and head in the same manner. However, it's a damn fine record and manages to avoid treading exactly the same ground its older sister did.

67
Pretty Much Amazing

With the excellent Depression Cherry out just two months ago, Beach House would have done better to sit on Lucky Stars, or maybe even have turned the whole thing into one crazy, sprawling double album.

60
Exclaim!

Thank Your Lucky Stars is definitely a treat ... but arriving so soon after Depression Cherry, it is bound to get lost in the shadow of its predecessor because frankly, it isn't nearly as compelling.

60
DIY

Unlike the previous LP, this record is more prone to striking with a golden, melodic touch.

60
NOW Magazine

Mood is the driving force, making it function best as background music, if occasionally forgettable.

60
Record Collector

For while it’s hard to begrudge any quality new release by a band of Beach House’s eminence, for a fan base still attuning itself to the subtle charms of Depression Cherry, this flawed follow-up might have been better served up refined and polished at a later date.

50
The Needle Drop

Dream pop duo Beach House impresses even less on their followup to Depression Cherry.

SnowyFighter
72

I think I’ve been in a chill vibe lately

Beach House is a group that barely misses, and they don’t miss with this album either. Is it their best album? No, but it still provides quality dream pop. Even this album is so refreshing to hear in a lot of ways, even though it isn’t their best output. It still sounds very lush, well produced, and beautiful. Majorette is a great opener, with a really nice chord progression and vocal melody. She’s So Lovely has a synth patch ... read more

Pieter
96

Somewhere Tonight makes me want to hug myself and cry in my bed.
Criminally underrated album

BGL13
78

beach house

m4dseason
85

I love Beach House, they have such an iconic aura that lets you know a song is theirs from the first few seconds. Despite that, it doesn't feel repetitive or boring it's amazing

blazznambertooo
68

"Thank Your Lucky Stars" is a confusing one in the BH catalog. Where each Beach House album either builds on the one before it, or tries a shake-up, this one feels a bit lopsided. With some songs that sound like they could be on the first 2 records, and songs that just sound... like they came from the cutting room floor. I don't hate it but, I can't say I am in love with it either. Songs like "She's So Lovely" or "Common Girl" are great, simple, dream pop songs ... read more

Felix_96
80

8/10

exceptional

Fav tracks: <all songs>

Purchasing Thank Your Lucky Stars from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1Majorette
4:00
82
2She's So Lovely
4:22
78
3All Your Yeahs
3:48
81
4One Thing
5:35
69
5Common Girl
3:07
67
6The Traveller
4:03
74
7Elegy to the Void
6:29
82
8Rough Song
5:14
83
9Somewhere Tonight
4:13
82
Total Length: 40 minutes
Comments (3)

Please stay on topic. To go off topic, head to the General Chat.

Sign in to comment
3mo
1y
2y


Added on: October 7, 2015