Crystal Castles - (III)
Critic Score
Based on 37 reviews
2012 Ratings: #346 / 1029
User Score
Based on 297 ratings
2012 Ratings: #233
Liked by 2 people
November 12, 2012 / Release Date
LP / Format
Fiction/Universal/Casablanca / Label
Suggest a Genre
Add
Abuse of this feature may prevent future contributions from your account.
Tags
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

90
NME

In toning down the shock and awe, they’ve revealed the beating heart at the centre of their work.

86
Paste

There’s something to be said of their “if it ain’t broke” methods, and this latest entry is a testament to their skill. Make no mistake: (III) is a great album. 

85
Prefix

(III) is far and above the most human of the band’s three records.

80
The 405

(III) may not be as shocking or challenging as I or even II, but it does mark progression for Crystal Castles, with some highly impressive dance tracks in one aspect, and moments of haunting tenderness in another.

80
Pitchfork

The success of (III) is how it brings you close enough to the evil that men do to be shocked, repulsed, and affected by it.

80
Drowned in Sound

I still can’t make up my mind whether Crystal Castles peaked too early and are now coasting, or if this is their new peak.

80
Consequence of Sound

III is less playful than the duo’s previous couple of offerings, but it’s thematic mood is much tighter and more fully realized.

80
No Ripcord

Rarely is an electronic album like sparked with such radical confidence.

80
Tiny Mix Tapes
While retaining some semblance of a structural foundation, in Crystal Castles’ case an “electronic” and “pop” foundation, the duo attempts to push its structural limitations to the exact point where the outside touches its body, porousness to parasites and contamination.
80
AllMusic
This is Crystal Castles' most serious set of songs yet, with a darker tone and streamlined sound that dovetails with its motifs of outsiders, injustices, and revolution.
80
PopMatters

(III) is the sound of two people jumping off the edge of the world by their own free will.

80
Exclaim!
Crystal Castles have delivered their most consistent album yet.
80
The Guardian

The most affecting songs on III don't sound like a band raging at the outside world, but rather experiencing a very personal kind of misery.

80
Billboard

Crystal Castles aren't as cold as they appear to be, but they are calculating-(III) is an expertly produced album that, at just nearly 40 minutes, leaves fans wanting more.

80
NOW Magazine
At that speed, the material comes across like some kind of mutant goth R&B, which sounds way better than it has any right to.
80
God Is in the TV
The Canadian duo have come along way since their debut back in 2008 with ‘III‘ being their most mature outing yet, hopefully for my sake IX will see the band going down the death metal route.
80
The Arts Desk
Canadian duo's third is their best so far.
80
The Independent
As usual, the listener can barely make out Glass's impassioned shrieks, but one cannot mistake the apocalyptic mood and intent.
80
Spill Magazine

Leaving previous copyright issues behind, Crystal Castles (III) deals with significantly less sampling, making the album distinguishably innovative, in a Crystal Castles kind of way.

80
Mixmag
Their third eponymous album, known for reasons of convenience as ‘(III)’, maintains their high quality threshold
75
Pretty Much Amazing

(III) is worthwhile in that it is an interesting take on dance music, yet that doesn’t seem quite enough for a group predicated on delivering an onslaught of emotional energy.

75
The Line of Best Fit

With III, Kath and Glass have refined their sound to a point of supreme clarity and confidence, but its progression is essentially conservative.

75
Spectrum Culture

III is appropriately titled, as it’s a progression for the band, but one that is also inextricably linked to its predecessors.

70
FACT Magazine

In running time and number of songs, (III) may be their shortest album, but it’s also their most cohesive personal statement yet.

60
musicOMH

It isn't what you'd expect with Crystal Castles. Normally you're left wondering at what point in proceedings they're going to try and set fire to your carpet.

60
The Fly

A quantum leap it ain’t – and Glass could do with putting her fangs back in – but ‘(III)’ has just enough up its sleeve to keep Crystal Castles on track.

60
The Skinny
In a remarkable and somewhat disappointing move, their third album sees the band calling in that debt, and aping the sound of several bands who followed in their wake.
60
Alternative Press
On their third full-length, Canadian duo Crystal Castles have drank deeper still from the well of discontent, resulting in 12 tracks that paint an even bleaker picture than their heretofore already grim worldview.
50
A.V. Club

Instead of anarchist dance jams full of crunchy 8-bit noise, (III) is more like a static-filled radio station fading in and out of range. 

50
Under The Radar

What’s left is moodier and muddier, overly dark and rarely danceable, with little of the excitement or energy we’re used to from this band.

50
Spin

The third record titled Crystal Castles is considerably less inviting and less extreme than its eponymous predecessors.

50
Slant Magazine
More importantly, it’s resulted in a dreary equalization of their aesthetic, one which not only removes most of its distinguishing characteristics, but kills the fun spot-the-sound-effect guessing game of their first two albums.
50
Sputnikmusic

Crystal Castles try to go all deep on us, but instead make a flat and boring record that loses what made the band so great in the first place.

40
The Needle Drop

While Crystal Castles continues writing some decent electropop tunes, on III the Toronto duo sees fit to decorate all of them with generic drum timbres and an overabundance of reverb.

40
The Observer

Now though – giving strength to that gloomy notion that most bands get more boring as they go on – it sounds more like music to get off your face to; there's very little on this third LP that could qualify as "experimental".

midnightbabe
79
This record was the calm before the storm for Crystal Castles. The storm being, of course, the really awful follow-up album, and all the allegations against Ethan Kath, the famed producer of CC. However, we must accept some songs in here are truly fantastic, regardless of what kind of awful person produced them.

Plague, the opening track, is a great dance song with some really off-kilter drums. The chorus in here is so explosive and anxiety-inducing it's really great.

It is followed by one of ... read more
Hummus
97
The most depressing, crushing, and emotional album I've ever heard, the more I listen to it the more I love it. I've tried writing full reviews for this thing, but I just don't think I can do it justice. It's a culmination of the increasingly sad direction Crystal Castles had been taking, resulting in an incredibly depressing, beautiful experience. That mixed with Alice's eventual break off from the band due to the abuse of Ethan Kath gives this album another layer to the project's depressed ... read more
Muratka
99
Отличается от всех остальных альбомов группы, явно видно что компьютеры не использовали.
RyanDWessel
80
Original Score: 50

I completely forgot that every single song on this album is fucking iconic.
EMR
43
Crystal Castles trade pretty much all of their crazy and distinct signature sounds from the two previous records for a more accessible and bland sonority with less intriguing songwriting and a particularly lifeless production style. There are still some decent electronic beats here and there, but overall, the duo let go of the playfulness and strange aesthetics that had drawn attention to their output before, indulging in some witchcraft territory that sounds really basic and uneventful. Maybe ... read more
Purchasing (III) from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

  1. Plague 
  2. Kerosene 
  3. Wrath of God 
  4. Affection 
  5. Pale Flesh 
  6. Sad Eyes 
  7. Insulin 
  8. Transgender 
  9. Violent Youth 
  10. Telepath 
  11. Mercenary 
  12. Child I Will Hurt You
Sign in to comment
No one has said anything yet.
Advertisement


Added on: September 26, 2012