Sign in to comment
20h
fitting Inbred into the narrative and tonal structure of Preacher's Daughter:
1. Family Tree (intro)
2. American Teenager
2.5 Crush
3. A House in Nebraska
3.5 Michelle Pfeiffer
4. Western Nights
4.5 God's Country
5. Family Tree
5.5 Inbred
6. Hard Times
7. Thoroughfare
7.5 Unpunishable
8. Gibson Girl
9. Ptolomaea
10. August Underground
11. Televangelism
11.5 Two-Headed Mother
12. Sun Bleached Flies
13. Strangers
2d
ptolemaea is more ominous than a kirby final boss
2d
YESSSS ORANGE MUST HEAR!!!! LETS GET THAT PURPLE!!!!!!!
3d
Justice for western nights
3d
house in nebraska best track
3d
wow i don’t like this at all ☹️
3d
Two more 9s to make up for the Pitchfork L.
3d
we have a blockomaniac running rampant in the streets
3d
LOL (replying to John, which I can’t do directly because I’m one of the very many he blocked :/ )
3d
halsey was ahead of her time for that pitchfork tweet
3d
can I block Pitchfork? I want to block Pitchfork.
4d
DESERVES 86 USER SCORE
4d
MUST HEAR LET'S GOOOOOO
4d
cmon let’s go red MHA
4d
“This Ethel Cain album…it’s NOT GOOD.”
- Hopefully not Melon
4d
pitchfork you nasty bitch
4d
The Pitchfork review makes some very valid points, though I will say it not recognizing the album’s story makes it incomplete…
4d
This is now a top 10 album of the year for me, I explained how the album grew on me in my last comment.
4d
pitchfork, if no one else will cheer for u, i will πŸ‘πŸ₯³πŸŽ‰

that being said, how is father of all by green day better than this???
4d
Pitchfork just took another L lmao
4d
Y’all mad at the number or the review?
4d
fuck pitchfork
4d
pitchfork is a shame goddamn i hate them
4d
pitchfork is blonde and gone
4d
The Pitchfork guy who reviewed this album gave this a 6.4 but gave "Father of All…" by Green Day a 6.7
4d
Thanks Pitchfork. This balances the overhype by some high critic scores, for an album that has too many flaws.
4d
halsey-pitchfork-tweet.jpg
4d
Witchfork
4d
Pitchfork is a joke
4d
Disappointed, but not surprised. Fucking pitchfork
4d
the chainsmkokers got a pitchfork 61. com'on
4d
pitchfork, just stop saying you are the MOST TRUSTED voice in music already. what a shame..............speechless.......
4d
(1/2)

Wow…talk about a grower…

50 —> 80

I missed the point and story of this album on my first listen. I didn’t realize there was a story at all, actually. But once I knew this, and once I gave the album a listen with this in mind, I was simply blown away by the storytelling itself. Sure, there are several incredibly conventional songs on this album, and a majority of the choruses get on my nerves to some extent, but this all ends up WORKING in its own ways to emphasize the innocence of the main character.

I also think that Ptolemaea is at absolute least a top 20 song of the year so far, and it along with August Underground and Televangelism are an incredible stretch of songs!
4d
pitchfork omfgaiifsofialslfuso
4d
What an embarrassingly lazy and shallow review from Pitchfork. Shouldn't have expected more.
4d
all that’s left now is fantano’s sweet light to decent 4
4d
p4k review says it’s 90 minutes when it’s 75, yeah they just be saying anything at this point
4d
It's 75 minutes long, isn't it? Why does Pitchfork say that it's 90?
4d
Pitchfork reviewers are on crack or smth lately
4d
You either die a hero... or live long enough to see yourself become AllMusic
4d
Pitchfork, you're done.
4d
if p4k doesn’t rate this by tonite im going to kms
4d
im sorry, why and how are people comparing this to lana del rey???? none of lana del rey’s albums sound like this.
4d
i'm having a hard time rating this with numbers
really enjoying it
4d
im kicking myself for not listening to this sooner. this REVERB. im only a few tracks in but im already so entranced
5d
Western nights is criminally underrated lmao fucking love that song
5d
Also I have never commented on this album, or rated it, or reviewed it.
5d
I don't recall ever interacting with Mr. John. I'm blocked.
Frequent Posters
Ethan_J_M
JohnLouisHoward
Nona
humm1ng_b1rd
clumsyduckling
okwowsuchok
Hydon
benjajpg
jcbal97
GoodCompany
Advertisement
Popular Album Discussion
Harry Styles - Harry's House
Kendrick Lamar - Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers
Rina Sawayama - Hold The Girl
Flume - Palaces
Everything Everything - Raw Data Feel
black midi - Hellfire
100 gecs - 10000 gecs
Black Country, New Road - Ants From Up There
The Smile - A Light for Attracting Attention
The Notorious B.I.G. - G.O.A.T.
Various Artists - Minions: The Rise of Gru (Official Soundtrack)
Ethel Cain - Preacher's Daughter
Advertisement

AOTY April Playlist
AOTY Discord
Forums