AOTY 2023

Pretty Years

Cymbals Eat Guitars - Pretty Years
Critic Score
Based on 15 reviews
2016 Ratings: #176 / 1002
User Score
Based on 115 ratings
2016 Ratings: #195
Liked by 1 person
September 16, 2016 / Release Date
LP / Format
Sinderlyn / Label
Indie Rock / Genre
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

91
A.V. Club

Pretty Years is joyous, revelatory, and the moment where the varied sounds of those past three records all come together.

90
PopMatters

Pretty Years is a document of Cymbals Eat Guitars’ most accessible music, D’Agostino’s richest vocal performances, and his ever-deepening lyrical acuity. It’s the best release yet from one of America’s most promising bands.

90
Exclaim!

This record's varied influences are held together by the mastery of both D'Agostino's songwriting and Congleton's production. It's unpredictable but immensely rewarding.

88
Sputnikmusic

While his vocals may remain an acquired taste ... his lyrics here, in conjunction with the band’s more nuanced sound and adventurous production, make Pretty Years their most complete record.

85
Under the Radar

They've glacially been building to this, one of the most inventive, adventurous, and best rock records of 2016.

85
The Line of Best Fit
With an emo revival seemingly taking shape at the moment Cymbals Eat Guitars may finally be able to find an audience, but the truth is they’re too good a band to need to fit into a scene. "Pretty Years" is one of the best guitar albums of the year.
80
Pitchfork

Every Cymbals Eat Guitars album has been dense, but none have covered as much ground as effectively as Pretty Years.

80
Drowned in Sound
Despite a noble resume, no other album comes closer to capturing the true essence of their onstage presence.
80
No Ripcord

In Pretty Years, the perennial late 90’s sounding rockers are stepping somewhat outside the box by introducing elements of heartland Americana and synth rock without turning away from their layered, guitar-heavy parts.

70
AllMusic

It takes advantage of a broader palette as Cymbals Eat Guitars continue to dip into more styles without losing their warped, crunchy center.

60
DIY

It just falls short of completely engulfing your interest and really exposing itself as anything completely fresh and inspiring. It’s pretty in places, but you’re left wishing that it was truly beautiful.

60
Kerrang!
A record packed with starry-eyed guitars, almost as if they were being beamed back down from the International Space Station.
50
Uncut

The Staten Island quartet blend the fixtures and fittings of noisy US slacker rock--Sonic Youth drones, Pavement squalls--but add a bubblegum pop sensibility. Their vocalist Joseph D'Agostino, however, remains something of an acquired taste.

63

Super abrasive, and certainly intentionally so. Personally a bit disappointing for me, as the opening cut "Finally" seemed to signal a movement towards more melodic and sonically appealing territory only to prove a red herring; still recommended for fans of the noisier side of the emo revival.

Felindie
80

Fav Tracks: Have a Heart, Wish, Close, Well

79

Fav tracks: have a heart, wish, 4th of july philadelphia, shrine

63

Super abrasive, and certainly intentionally so. Personally a bit disappointing for me, as the opening cut "Finally" seemed to signal a movement towards more melodic and sonically appealing territory only to prove a red herring; still recommended for fans of the noisier side of the emo revival.

Felindie
80

Fav Tracks: Have a Heart, Wish, Close, Well

79

Fav tracks: have a heart, wish, 4th of july philadelphia, shrine

Purchasing Pretty Years from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1Finally
4:01
2Have a Heart
3:02
3Wish
4:04
4Close
4:16
5Dancing Days
5:02
64th of July 2015 (Sandy)
3:29
7Beam
2:14
8Mallwalking
4:38
9Well
4:15
10Shrine
6:41
Total Length: 41 minutes
Comments

Please stay on topic. To go off topic, head to the General Chat.

Sign in to comment
No one has said anything yet.


Added on: May 23, 2016