AOTY 2023

Desire, I Want To Turn Into You

Caroline Polachek - Desire, I Want To Turn Into You
Critic Score
Based on 23 reviews
2023 Ratings: #11 / 746
Year End Rank: #2
User Score
2023 Ratings: #28
Liked by 1,471 people
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

100
PopMatters

Caroline Polachek dives into the contradictory crux of the human experience on Desire, I Want to Turn Into You, an album of breathtakingly original pop songs.

100
Evening Standard
After a long career, this grandstanding collection sounds like Polachek’s big moment.
100
Dork

On ‘Desire, I Want To Turn Into You’, she offers up hope, catharsis and real euphoria. A record of love in its initial ravenous infatuated rumblings, and occasionally when it erupts into something bigger.

100
The Telegraph
The sheer range of Polachek’s songcraft makes you realise you are in the presence of a commanding talent. She has drawn comparison with Kate Bush and Bjork, not because she sounds like them, but because she has a similar blend of extraordinary vocal ability, florid imagination, and genre-bending boldness.
100
DIY
It embraces the unconventional with resounding ease, finding its voice in the skilled hands of two of pop’s most forward-thinking pioneers, both busy rethinking just what it can be.
100
The Skinny
Caroline Polachek stretches the boundaries of the surreal as she explores her desire for desire itself on her compelling new record.
92
Paste

Polachek's sophomore effort centers on a need for closeness while pushing her sound into the stratosphere.

90
Still Listening
Caroline Polachek gifts fans with one of the best art pop records of the year.
90
Clash
Despite only being February, Caroline Polachek has set a serious precedent for any pop releases that follow it this year. She is an artist completely in her own lane, refusing to conform, every moment on this record a vicissitude. Her commitment to her craft is undeniable, her talent indisputable.
90
Exclaim!

While 2019's shimmering Pang was rich with ideas but sometimes light on songcraft  — Desire, I Want to Turn Into You feels like the arrival of Caroline Polachek, a statement of intent that finally lassos her myriad musical ambitions into something singular.

90
The Line of Best Fit

The tight 12-track collection is doe-eyed, confident, and sonically varied – not only is it wholly different from its predecessor, it’s a portrait of someone in love. From its opening screams welcoming the listener to her world, Desire, I Want to Turn Into You is an island where romance is meshed with clearly focus artistic vision.

90
Under the Radar
She delivers an effortless balance between ambition and accessibility, offering a record that is both a deeply layered work of art and full of euphoric escapist joy.
90
AllMusic

With Desire, I Want to Turn into You, Polachek breaks free from outside expectations and transforms her inner anxieties into an intoxicating pop euphoria.

88
Spectrum Culture
Using a three-ring circus of sounds and voices, Polachek leaves no stone unturned on a mission to transcend common notions of desire.
87
Pitchfork
Caroline Polachek’s best album of her career is a transformative pop experience, a passionate, richly melodic odyssey into the darkest corners of love.
86
Beats Per Minute
Albums like this are rare and special, highlighting pop’s capacity to sculpt our emotions and steer us towards something better beyond the horizon.
82
Northern Transmissions

Desire, I Want To Turn Into You is Polocheks best collection thus far and that is saying a lot as her last release Pang is almost pure pop perfection. With this album, Polochek’s constant desire to dig deeper adds more depth to the songs than some of her precious work and it’s really revelatory stuff.

80
Rolling Stone

Her second album stands out as a glittering showcase for her encyclopedic musical knowledge and formidable voice.

80
The Forty-Five
On ‘Desire…’ Polachek is staring out at the sunny horizon and beyond. The experimental star not only surrenders to big pop moments, but signs hand-painted details where you can choose to follow the clues in search of something deeper, or simply lose yourself in the ocean swell.
60
Loud and Quiet

The end of what has been a convoluted rollout ... is a muddled album that seems less sure of itself than 2019’s Pang; this kind of maximalism involves walking a tightrope between gaudy and glorious, and Desire is poised one minute, wobbly the next.

60
No Ripcord

Both Welcome to My Island and I Believe are true pop bangers, and Smoke has an arrestingly powerful bassline that melds beautifully with her shimmering voice. Still, there are enough missteps for my palate that keep this squarely in the “just fine” column and keep me scratching my head about its overall reception.

60
NME

The follow-up to 2019’s ‘Pang’ is hindered by a lengthy rollout, but Polachek’s sheer ambition is never in doubt.

BaddieBaphomet
100

God I love being queer

Singer, songwriter, producer, geese screamer: Caroline Polachek. She’s been at this for a while, though you’d be forgiven if you thought she was a newer face, as this latest phase of her career feels entirely separated from what came before. She got her start in the indie pop duo Chairlift with Patrick Wimberly, and while they never had a huge hit single or album chart topper they still managed to garner a fairly decent following that’s only garnered ... read more

LonelyHipHopFan
75

RANT TIME!!!

So, I'm usually not one to share personal stuff, but I will make an exception just this time. I'm very emotional right now, so this might be an incomprehensible mess, if you don't want to deal with that, just skip this one. I am gay. I have supressed that fact for most of my life, but I have come to terms with it by now. Still, I have never told anyone about it. It's pretty lame to come out as a 20 year old and it's even lamer to come out to people who I've never met, never will ... read more

Chode
93

Before Caroline Polachek drops pop album of the year… anybody wanna admit they got a crush on me 🥺

What makes a good pop song? This is a question I find myself constantly pondering, especially when listening to most of the dog shit that populates the top of the Billboard charts. At its core, pop music is music at its most accessible- prioritizing catchiness and accessibility above all else. This is why 95% of mainstream pop artists suck monster cock. Very few artists strive to push ... read more

CarterTheHuman
89

simple on the surface, but turn any song up and you'll notice so much detail waiting to be unpacked.

Conky5454
70

This Album is so smooth and ethereal sounding with vocals that are supper impressive and creatively delivered. I loved listening to this album even though the first 2 songs are ok, the middle is amazing. But then it gets a bit weaker with track 7,8 and 9. I still think there are redeeming qualities with those songs but I personally just don't vibe with them as much, then it kicks backs with some of my favorites. Although my absolute favorite song is sunset. Album art 9/10

Purchasing Desire, I Want To Turn Into You from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1Welcome To My Island
3:52
88
2Pretty In Possible
3:36
84
3Bunny Is a Rider
3:13
85
4Sunset
2:42
87
5Crude Drawing Of An Angel
3:28
81
6I Believe
4:07
86
7Fly To You
4:05
feat. Grimes, Dido
82
8Blood And Butter
4:27
87
9Hopedrunk Everasking
3:19
77
10Butterfly Net
4:36
84
11Smoke
2:57
85
12Billions
4:57
89
Total Length: 45 minutes

Please stay on topic. To go off topic, head to the General Chat.

Sign in to comment
6h
8h
1d
1d
1w


Added on: December 5, 2022