Untitled

Critic Score
Based on 16 reviews
2008 Ratings: #478 / 847
User Score
2008 Ratings: #496
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
The Independent
For my money, Nas remains New York's most potent rapper, operating with an insight and intelligence few exponents can equal.
90
PopMatters

Illmatic was stylistically brilliant and incalculably influential, but Untitled is a more mature, emotionally-driven, and philosophically-complex piece of work. It’s also a masterpiece.

90
HipHopDX

Although controversy and constant criticism from the album’s initial title may have placed doubts on how great of an album it can be, none of this has stopped Untitled from lyrically being his most consistent and daring project since Illmatic.

85
RapReviews.com

Even if the music isn’t extraordinary, Nas himself is legendary on “Untitled” – and as long as racism is relevant, so is this album.

83
Entertainment Weekly
In a summer of ''Lollipop,'' it’s refreshing to hear a complicated record that doesn’t shy from grown-up ambition.
80
Drowned in Sound
Social progress may seem stillborn, but hip-hop, still, isn't dead.
80
AllMusic
A couple tracks might sonically resemble inferior versions of years-old tracks that helped make Nas a hip-hop deity and, nearly ten years after Nas was first accused of selling out, he might still sound a little awkward over radio-friendly productions. But the MC has never made an album as engrossing or as necessary as this one.
80
Rolling Stone

In short, it is the most intensely political record since the heyday of Public Enemy and Ice Cube, with Nas sounding as virtuosic as he did on his 1994 debut, Illmatic.

70
Slant Magazine
The lyrics are all terrific; the beats, not so much.
60
Consequence of Sound
There are not a lot of blatantly negative things to say about this album, but it has very few highlights.
50
Paste

Unfortunately, no amount of slick beats and swagger can camouflage Untitled’s defects.

45
Coke Machine Glow
No, I’m not crying. I’m trying not to yawn.
40
The Observer
As ever, this most eloquent of rappers is stronger on zingers than philosophical coherence. But his dismal taste in beats strands his poetry in a sea of mediocrity.
38
Pitchfork

On Untitled you get to decide whether you prefer Nas thoroughly exploring half-assed concepts or half-assedly exploring thorough concepts.

20
Tiny Mix Tapes
Ultimately, Nas’ decision to sacrifice lyrical and aesthetic sensibility for controversy, hype, and pop-appeal exposes the commodification and hollowness of his artistic voice and vision.
Toasttee
87

Thanks for 200 followers.
NAS DIVE #10

Despite being the most pop-esc album I've heard from Nas, he makes up for it with his lyricism and messages. It is criminal how underrated this album is. Although the production is meh and some songs do get boring at times, those moments are few and far between. I had holding off the Nas Dive for while, due to a mix of dread for the next few albums and a burnout on Nas, but this album gave me renowned hope to finish the dive and answer the ... read more

fullercaleb
50

'Untitled' is such an interesting album, because while it has Nas' most mainstream sound yet, the lyrics are stronger and more direct than ever.

There are more R&B/soul hooks on this album than we've heard before from Nas' catalog, and the instrumentation does a fine job keeping up with the rise of synths and electronics. Though, the first two tracks don't follow that formula, and I was quite looking forward to hearing a darker piano-laden songs, but that trend didn't continue.

Despite ... read more

TVeno
36

I'll take rhymes with shit beats for 400, Alex.

Yeah that's kind of the extent of what I have to say. The first half of the album was alright, not great but could be worse. It had some good songs like America and You Can't Stop Us Now, even if it had many skips like the entirely unenthralling intro Queens Get the Money, Make the World Go Round and the goofy as can be Testify. The second half, though. Jesus Christ. Everything after track 9 is plagued with what I can only call ... read more

More popular reviews
RupertMartin
74

easily Nas's most aggressive and political album. It's very straight to the point in the writing, which i see many calling "preachy" but i'd disagree. the writing seems very intentional and for the most part it works really well. I absolutely love songs like Queens Get the Money, Sly Fox, I.'.M._.T.O.O._W.H.I.T.E._.T.O.O._.T.Y.P.E._.T.H.I.S._.W.O.R.D (The Slave and the Master), Y'all My Whiteboys and Black president. o really don't get the hate for Sly ... read more

FatherTime5
62

gets worse from start to finish

Satolayte
83

Nas falls off after 6 songs on this record which is sad because he was on track for a 10/10 album, unfortunately in life you don't get what you want all the time.

More recent reviews
Purchasing Untitled from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Year End Lists

#43/Rolling Stone
#49/PopMatters

More Lists
Sign in to comment
1w
1mo
3mo
3mo
6mo

April Playlist