AOTY 2023

falling or flying

Jorja Smith - falling or flying
Critic Score
Based on 21 reviews
2023 Ratings: #547 / 746
User Score
Based on 505 ratings
2023 Ratings: #625
Liked by 33 people
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

90
PopMatters

Jorja Smith’s Falling or Flying is quite an accomplishment and an excellent vehicle for her estimable talents. It’s a low-key yet unequivocal triumph.

90
DIY
A record unafraid to run off in different directions.
80
Clash

Smith continues to shirk commercial viability, stripping away sheen and artifice, presenting herself as dimensional; flawed, bruised, exposed, at times disbelieving, but ultimately worthy of love.

80
XS Noize

Falling or Flying flies high when honest and musically deep and, at times, loose and fancy-free. The songs with these qualities are the most unique and demonstrate that Jorja Smith deserves to stand tall amongst the many A-listers she has collaborated with.

80
Evening Standard
This marks a real step up for the much-hyped artist, who has consistantly pushed back against industry expectations.
80
The Forty-Five
Jorja Smith's long-awaited second album is a sonic adventure that never stops surprising.
80
Dork
It would be very easy for an artist as gifted as Jorja to coast along on some nice songs that highlight her captivating voice, but instead, she’s made a record that both challenges and enthrals in equal measure. Combining lively club stormers and lush R&B along with a dash of genuine indie rock rowdiness, it’s a compelling mix.
80
NME
On her second album – featuring dancefloor heater 'Little Things' – the Walsall-raised star finds her rhythm with an expanded sonic palette.
80
AllMusic

Compared to the debut, the songs are a little tighter in structure, communicate more, and bounce from style to style -- whereas Lost & Found presented an evolved, commercially minded brand of street soul -- with introspective R&B always somewhere in the mix.

80
musicOMH
British soul singer returns with a coherent second album, which sees her explore and develop her own sound.
76
Pitchfork
The UK singer’s earthy, sumptuous new album explores her ambivalent relationship to fame. It soars when it lets loose.
76
Spectrum Culture

An effortlessly produced and performed record, falling or flying finds Jorja Smith exploring new sounds and the world around her and is a welcome follow-up to her debut.

70
The Line of Best Fit
In the relatively short timespan since Jorja Smith’s proper introduction to large audiences, she’s already mastered the art of the slow burn – and her flame isn’t waning just yet.
70
HipHopDX
Smith is clearly maturing and unafraid to sing about both her failings and her partners but her sincerity can sometimes get bogged down by uninspired instrumentals. At her most emotional, Smith is a vocal and lyrical powerhouse whose peak is still yet to come.
60
Exclaim!

falling or flying may fall a bit short of the expectations set by her debut, but it does fly in the face of what you'd expect of someone on their second outing as a solo artist. It's a solid effort despite some missteps — among the clutter is some of the best material of Smith's young career.

60
Loud and Quiet
It’s hardly surprising that given the choice of falling or flying, the latter triumphs. Smith uses the album to confront the here and now, working with producer duo DAMEDAME* across all 16 tracks to make sense of mid-air.
60
The Arts Desk
Jorja Smith’s neo-soul and R&B – all muscular back beats, slinky bass lines and guitar licks – sounds better than ever on falling.
60
Record Collector
Things turn introspective as Smith deals with self-doubt and toxic treatment, with some beautiful results, particularly Backward, which has a gorgeous strings coda, and the sparse pulse of the choirfeaturing Try And Fit In.
40
Mojo

Smith often finds herself stuck in a musical straitjacket of tired R&B tropes, rarely able to break out of a narrow comfort zone. But on the odd occasion she takes a risk, as with the jazzy house groove Little Things, the effect is sensational. If Smith truly wants to soar, first she’ll have to conquer her fear of falling.

UltimateLifeFrm
60

The long awaited sophomore album has arrived from British R&B singer Jorja Smith, who's been a rising act since her breakthrough in 2018 with her single "Blue Lights".

Falling or Flying approaches themes of breakups and relationships with her friends, former friends & herself. Personal matter that shows her growth over the years, which makes for great stories to tell that can be musically impactful.

Knowing what Jorja is capable of, having heard "Lost & Found" ... read more

Missing_Lyriks
64

R&B nerd over here, and I thought we were on a hot streak with R&B lately.

But i guess that streak was falling.

Now, don’t get me wrong, I know NOTHING about Jorja. Girl only got my listen because she reminds me of my favorite fruit and because there was nothing that peaked my interest this week (may listen to the new Armand Hammer project though since people are liking it so much and it’s got funny track names). What I’ve learned from her though is that she ... read more

BaddieBaphomet
60

NO NUANCE REVIEW

Certainly well performed, but fairly unremarkable.

55

From being a very laid back soft r&b artist with examples of don't watch me cry, this is a slight step up for Jorja Smith with her long awaited album. And it isn't too rewarding.

punisherforever
53

Sweet voice as always but...

I really don't know what to say because if i did end up hating or loving it i would write my opinion and everything i feel about it but this one is just ok. She has a great voice as always had but most of the songs were boring and sounded the same, of course there are strong songs but is just like 4 or 5 and that's it. I really wish i could write and opinion about this but is difficult. The only thing i have an opinion is that STOP BODYSHAMING HER YOU FUCKING RATS.

DFSniker
50

Not her best work.

Purchasing falling or flying from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1Try Me
3:33
81
2She Feels
3:12
72
3Little Things
3:24
82
4Flights skit
0:17
47
5Feelings
3:57
feat. J Hus
71
6Falling or flying
3:24
79
7GO GO GO
2:25
67
8Try and fit in
1:56
67
9Greatest Gift
3:12
feat. Lila Iké
74
10Broken is the man
2:12
68
11Make sense
2:21
68
12Too many times
2:38
66
13Lately
2:07
68
14BT69 JJY
0:25
52
15Backwards
3:44
77
16What if my heart beats faster?
4:52
82
Total Length: 43 minutes

Please stay on topic. To go off topic, head to the General Chat.

Sign in to comment
1w
1mo
1mo
1mo
1mo


Added on: May 18, 2023