Overview
User Reviews

Comments (14,461)

Sign in to comment
4h
i feel like im the only one who doesnt like carnival
9h
if problematic was on any other album it would be 100% on green
11h
HE REMOVED IT WTF
12h
I'd rather have this so much than another JIK
14h
YEEZUS SZN APROACHING
15h
"Fuck Kanye" "I love Kanye" I EAT SAND 🏖🏖🏖🏖🏖🏖🏖🏖🏖🏖🏖
16h
Fuck Kanye, He’s a Nazi
18h
how is this the lowest rated Ty$ project since 2012
21h
im starting to think vultures 1 comment section as a different entity seperate from aoty
1d
Lowest rated critic album, amen
1d
the 808's and yeezus effect from this is gonna go crazy
1d
"57"
1d
i am going to be fr with y'all carnival fucking sucks
1d
They actually got rid of the bots... fair play
1d
https://music.apple.com/us/album/vultures-1/1731230943 carti is credited on carnival and (for some reason) rich the kid is a main artist on beg forgiveness
1d
COME WITH ME
I GOT BOOZE
AND THAT DRIP MISTIIIING
2d
wouldve been better if he merged the best songs from the 3 albums into 1
2d
Kanye can keep the other 2 parts
2d
Isnt duplee the guy that made that video with about hip hop not being positive kendrick lamar and lean on the thumbnail
2d
glad to see this still dropping
2d
duplee is a breathing dummy
2d
Oh yay it's finally leaving popular discussion
2d
This is just mediocre. It’s not even bad enough to freak out over, or good enough to call the best album this decade. It’s just average. Nothing more, nothing less
2d
Nice to see Hattie is still schizoposting after leaving this shoutbox lol
2d
Like i get Duplee but his logic is so twisted. Half the songs on this album are like ;literally earrapes so i mean yeah separate the art from artist and you get some really good cuts but some dogcrap ones.
2d
Alvin chorus:
BABY DONT KEEP ME UP, LEUKEMIA 🔥🔥🔥
BABY DONT KEEP ME UP, LEUKEMIA 🔥🔥🔥
BABY DONT KEEP ME UP, LEUKEMIA 🔥🔥🔥
2d
bro's spotify pfp💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
3d
goin to taco bell y'all want sumn
3d
The Big Day and an NF album in the "You May Also Like" section yeah he fell off
3d
Good is song of the year so far need it back on spotify NOW
3d
atleast burn is a banger
3d
If this was made by any other rap artist, this would be in the red, and their career would be over for good.
3d
After deciding to do a full review of the Kanye catalogue, I'm feeling pretty sure that everything after TLOP (Kids See Ghosts excluded) is half-assed and loaded with cringe personal rants anyway
3d
There are only 2 types of people in the world now: people who loved this and people who didn't
3d
I'm losing respect for fantano the guy is acting like a manchild on Twitter
3d
Every time I remember that this is only Vultures 1 I get scared. The other two volumes will likely never release but I'm kinda okay with that 💀
3d
A Ty and Carti collab project would be heat ngl
3d
its sad how washed ye is. he ruins every song he jumps on
3d
KEEP FUK SUMN IN GREEN
PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD
3d
if beg forgiveness finished like it should it could be one of my fav kanye songs of all time
4d
Dont get me wrong i think its great we are potentially getting 3 whole albums but the missed potential of having one Big album with all of the best songs is a huge loss.

Can you imagine a tracklist with a completed Everybody, Burn, River, Time Moving Slow, Slide, Beg Forgivness, Good Dont Die Carnival etc? Lowkey would be Yes best album since TLOP and might have that beat if they really took their time with this record and fleshed the concept out more instead of spreading it out over 3 albums.

Still looking forward to the next volumes tho
4d
This was originally a 83 after it first dropped 💀
4d
i love paid so much so fucking much
4d
updated my score again lol
4d
Alvin > Travis Scott on Fuk Sum
4d
FUK SUMN is probably the only track from here i listen to at this point. I can actually hear Peggy on there with it's synths and shit. still that track is not perfect and meanders a lot. but yeah that's it for this album.
4d
I listened to CARNIVAL, thought it was okay, but now it's stuck in my head and I fucking hate it
1
2
3
4
...
143
Frequent Posters
fisfis
TomBejoy
Metformin
Sonicfire35
knifestruggle
ListeningWind
Prismoz
NP6
rices
HattieJosh
Advertisement
Popular Album Discussion
Yeat - 2093
Quadeca - SCRAPYARD
MGMT - Loss of Life
Taylor Swift - The Tortured Poets Department
Friko - Where we've been, Where we go from here
Kid Cudi - INSANO (NITRO MEGA)
Allie X - Girl With No Face
Kanye West - The College Dropout
French Montana - Mac & Cheese 5 (Versions)
French Montana - Mac & Cheese 5
Advertisement

January Playlist
AOTY Discord