AOTY 2023

M A N I A

Fall Out Boy - M A N I A
Critic Score
Based on 15 reviews
2018 Ratings: #837 / 889
User Score
2018 Ratings: #773
Liked by 30 people
Sign In to rate and review

CRITIC REVIEWS

80
DIY
‘M A N I A’ was always going to be an interesting ride, but it’s also a deftly-created rock album with a cutting-edge twist.
80
Kerrang!
They're strutting along a tightrope without a downward glance here.
80
Upset

Impossible to peg down or box in, ‘M A N I A’ sounds like Fall Out Boy enjoying being Fall Out Boy, and taking full advantage of all the freedom that offers.

75
GIGsoup
The newest album from the largely popular emo band is a solid release but it will not compete with their past albums.
75
The Young Folks

All in all, M A N I A is a welcome expansion of Fall Out Boy’s arsenal of songs about the vicissitudes of life and love.

70
The Sydney Morning Herald

Not every grand plan pays off – the Latin-pop of Hold Me Tight Or Don't sounds like an emo band at karaoke – but considering Fall Out Boy scrapped much of the record late last year, for the most part Mania feels worth the wait.

60
NME

From chiming tropical jam ‘Hold Me Tight Or Don’t’ to the batshit but brilliant EDM of ‘Young And Menace’, the quartet have thrown everything they’ve done previously out of the window.

60
Rolling Stone

The album is less a reboot than a re-affirmation of their ability to fuse over-the-top oversharing and Queen-ly operatic stomp with an elastic vision of pop.

60
The Guardian

Mania doesn’t have enough big tunes ... to really pull it off, but the band deserve a lot of credit for such continual reinvention.

50
AllMusic

Instead of making Fall Out Boy seem fresh, these electronic inflections wind up hinting at the group's age, as this frenetic music never seems to come as easily as the familiar amped-up blue-eyed soul and heady punk-pop. That transparent sense of labor does indeed make M A N I A seem manic, with Fall Out Boy not so much chasing trends as demonstrating that they know something is happening, they just don't know what it is.

50
A.V. Club

Since around 2007’s Infinity On High, the key to enjoying Fall Out Boy has been letting go of their pop-punk past and embracing the pop band that always hid in plain sight. That was a chore on American Beauty/American Psycho, but less so on Mania. As endorsements go, that’s pretty qualified.

50
Exclaim!

To step out musically is to drop out commercially and though frequently redundant, M A N I A remains a fun listen.

40
Spectrum Culture

Their latest, Mania, feels like a Fall Out Boy album in name only, equidistant to their roots as New Order was to Joy Division.

40
Evening Standard
Unfortunately, a decade on from their commercial and creative peak, their pop-punk has lost its panache.
30
Drowned in Sound
This is a feeble gesture of benign, stadium-sized pop that’s been cynically constructed, artificially beefed-up and saturated beyond the point of listenability. It’s gonna sell millions.
exception
20

You guys see the cool spacing between the letters of the title? God this band is fucking innovative.

BradTasteMusic
21

Full review on my YouTube channel: "Brad Taste In Music"

There is so much wrong with this album that it feels like a waste of time talking about. It has 5 new songs... nothing worth checking out. The singing is consistently off key, FOB makes some of the worst musical decisions of their lives on some of these songs, It is all over the place, and I am afraid to touch this monstrosity ever again. The writing is almost nonexistent. What an embarrassment of an album

This is NOT okay ... read more

BaddieBaphomet
10

Like a of people my age, Fall Out Boy was one of the first rock bands that I got into as a kid on my own, not being shown them by my parents or anything but finding them and buying their music with my own money. It was not uncommon for a lot of young millennials/old zoomers for Fall Out Boy to be “baby’s-first-‘alternative’-band”. Looking back now that I’m adult, I can say that Fall Out Boy’s music hasn’t aged the best, even less so than a bunch ... read more

BOYSDONTCRY09
30

A lot of ideas on this record exucuted very very poorly.

msheidiho
63

ok guys it wasn't that bad. some songs were pretty good.

goo3yKing
10

This is really the most bland and generic thing I’ve heard in a minute. I sort of like their earlier stuff a little bit I guess but this is just awful, sorry

Purchasing M A N I A from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Year End Lists

#21/Rock Sound
#35/Kerrang!
#47/Upset
/Alternative Press

Please stay on topic. To go off topic, head to the General Chat.

Sign in to comment
1mo
1mo
8mo
10mo
1y


Added on: April 27, 2017