Weezer (Black Album)

Weezer - Weezer (Black Album)
Critic Score
Based on 27 reviews
2019 Ratings: #763 / 771
User Score
Based on 781 ratings
2019 Ratings: #926
Liked by 8 people
March 1, 2019 / Release Date
LP / Format
Crush, Atlantic / Label
Dave Sitek / Producer
Pop Rock / Genres
weezer.com / Website
Sign In to rate and review



Even doused in black point, distorted beyond recognition or trying for some reason to spit bars, Weezer still maintain the ability to surprise, and even brush with something transcendental in a bridge here ... or a chorus there.


The Black Album feels like the most fully realized latter-day Weezer album: it may flagrantly draw from old and new elements of pop culture, yet it belongs to its own feverish world.

Drowned in Sound

Their recent uptick in form had been supported by successfully channelled home comforts, but on Black they sound fully invested into exploring, and more than capable of handling, a new pop sound.


On the innovative Black Album, the pop-rock greats serve us a selection of well-evolved bangers.

A.V. Club

With the band remaining prolific and energized, is it that interesting to spend so much time thinking about a 25-year-old masterpiece? Maybe it’s more important that Weezer’s idiosyncrasies feel honest again.


It’s a great - albeit mis-matched - collection of songs.


The LA band have made a wilfully goofy album whose jokes wear pretty thin, pretty fast – though this is a largely solid alt-pop record nonetheless.

Rolling Stone

The band’s 13th album portends a musical change-up, but its core is still precise, poker-faced pop-rock.


At times, the Black Album feels like an awkward band trying to hang out with ‘the kids’, at others, it feels like a brilliant mind trying to work out where it fits in the modern world.


This striving for the new and different comes at a cost. There’s no emotional throughline on The Black Album, no grand statement that continues from one track to the next. The songs never blur together, but they also don’t tell a story as the sum of their parts.

Spectrum Culture

As uneven and muddled as it can be, The Black Album gets one clear message through from Cuomo to the thirty- and forty-somethings who loved him in the ‘90s: thanks for everything, but it’s time we all moved on.

Pretty Much Amazing

This is the most disjointed record in Weezer’s discography. Its probably not the worst but its right there with Raditude and Make Believe.

FLOOD Magazine

To the extent that it adds new wrinkles to the Weezer formula while still sounding every bit like a Weezer album, you can call this a smashing success. But to the extent that anyone would ever use this music as the backdrop to a night out—sans irony, anyway—well, that’s much more debatable.

No Ripcord

Cuomo shrugs as he jumps from one middle-aged errand to the next, hoping to plop back to his bed so he can go back to daydreaming about the Pacific.

Spill Magazine

Overall, Black Album is a weaker release by a band that seems to be lacking direction. Despite some catchy highlights, too many songs are skippable with uninteresting music and empty lyrics.

Consequence of Sound

While it is absolutely no crime for a band to flirt with sonic experimentation, a disastrous affair can brew when the flirtation results in a body of work that is far more two-dimensional and hollow than what the band have proven capable of doing through their decades of previous work.

The Needle Drop

Weezer's Black Album resumes the band's nosedive.


Perhaps, sadly, the most damning criticism one can make of Weezer here is that they sound boring.


Weezer's latest is an utterly skippable collection that'd be entirely unremarkable if not for the fact it was released by Weezer. Better luck next time, Rivers.


Whilst it is undeniably their most experimental work, the record listens like an audio representation of Theresa May’s awkward robot-like dancing – confused, cringingly uncomfortable and desperately out of touch.

The 405

With The Black Album, Weezer tries to experiment with different sounds, only to achieve results that are staler than before - and of course, bumbling lyrics that are as dorky than anything they’ve ever written.


Weezer's Black Album shrinks to the low ambition of phoned-in karaoke over plastic keyboard preloads.

Under The Radar

Their sixth self-titled album is a new low, even by their comically slack standards.

Jay-Z & Metallica did not deserve this.
Y'all, stop giving one line reviews the top comment. My quip wasn't even that funny wtf. That said, no deep fried memes came out of this so I'm here to torture you with a review instead.

So guess who knew this was going to be bad from day one...that's right THIS GUY! You might be thinking "but Gav, that's not so hard to do" but this album actually has some history to it. I feel context is key for this one so buckle up for some WEEZY HISTORY.

This album was actually announced three ... read more
Rivers the type of guy to swear on a track and then go to the confessional booth at church to repent to whatever anime waifu he’s currently worshipping.
Hmm. So this a dumpster fire.

Weezer haven't had the best couple of years, with their records being flammed from head to toe (deservedly). It was clear that Weezer just wanted to have fun from the moment I hit play on The Teal Album (doesn't excuse it from being god awful). And it's also clear that Weezer want to move to a more pop centric sound on this album. From the funk layerd Can't Fight The Hustle, to the Uber hip hop influenced Zombie Bastards, it's very clear from the first couple of ... read more
You would think that after two and a half decades of being together, Rivers would have made up his fuckin mind about what he wanted his band to sound like.

This record was incredibly catchy and Weezer have become fantastic at making catchy tunes to sing along to, but goddamn the lengths they will go to to do so make me uncomfortable at times. Some of those lyrics were just downright cringy.
Purchasing Weezer (Black Album) from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.

Track List

  1. Can't Knock the Hustle
  2. Zombie Bastards
  3. High As a Kite
  4. Living In L.A.
  5. Piece of Cake
  6. I’m Just Being Honest
  7. Too Many Thoughts In My Head
  8. The Prince Who Wanted Everything
  9. Byzantine
  10. California Snow
Sign in to comment

Added on: November 11, 2017