AOTY 2021
Sloppy Jane - Madison
Sloppy Jane
Madison
LP
75
critic score
(3)
78
user score
(112)
Japanese Breakfast - Sable
Japanese Breakfast
Sable
Soundtrack
78
critic score
(2)
74
user score
(22)
Devendra Banhart & Noah Georgeson - Refuge
Devendra Banhart & Noah Georgeson
Refuge
LP
73
critic score
(4)
67
user score
(36)
Khruangbin - Mordechai Remixes
Khruangbin
Mordechai Remixes
Remix
70
critic score
(1)
70
user score
(12)
Fenne Lily - BREECH (acoustic)
Fenne Lily
BREECH (acoustic)
EP
64
user score
(4)
Durand Jones & The Indications - Private Space
Durand Jones & The Indications
Private Space
LP
74
critic score
(9)
76
user score
(106)
Phosphorescent - The BBC Sessions
Phosphorescent
The BBC Sessions
EP
75
critic score
(1)
Japanese Breakfast - Jubilee
Japanese Breakfast
Jubilee
LP
86
critic score
(26)
80
user score
(1,889)
shame - Live In The Flesh
shame
Live In The Flesh
Live
77
user score
(8)
Claud - Super Monster
Claud
Super Monster
LP
80
critic score
(14)
65
user score
(357)
shame - Drunk Tank Pink
shame
Drunk Tank Pink
LP
79
critic score
(28)
74
user score
(1,369)
Aaron Frazer - Introducing...
Aaron Frazer
Introducing...
LP
77
critic score
(8)
69
user score
(271)
Phoebe Bridgers - Copycat Killer
Phoebe Bridgers
Copycat Killer
EP
71
critic score
(9)
73
user score
(262)
Kevin Morby - Sundowner
Kevin Morby
Sundowner
LP
73
critic score
(17)
71
user score
(107)
Fenne Lily - BREACH
Fenne Lily
BREACH
LP
78
critic score
(12)
72
user score
(118)
Bright Eyes - Down in the Weeds Where the World Once Was
Bright Eyes
Down in the Weeds Where the World Once Was
LP
79
critic score
(30)
71
user score
(382)
Khruangbin - Mordechai
Khruangbin
Mordechai
LP
75
critic score
(23)
69
user score
(420)
Phoebe Bridgers - Punisher
Phoebe Bridgers
Punisher
LP
88
critic score
(41)
84
user score
(3,387)
Khruangbin & Leon Bridges - Texas Sun
Khruangbin & Leon Bridges
Texas Sun
EP
76
critic score
(7)
71
user score
(190)
Bill Fay - Countless Branches
Bill Fay
Countless Branches
LP
82
critic score
(12)
69
user score
(181)
Bleached - Don't You Think You've Had Enough?
Bleached
Don't You Think You've Had Enough?
LP
71
critic score
(14)
69
user score
(47)
Khruangbin - Hasta El Cielo
Khruangbin
Hasta El Cielo
LP
68
critic score
(8)
61
user score
(51)
Alex Lahey - The Best of Luck Club
Alex Lahey
The Best of Luck Club
LP
75
critic score
(16)
70
user score
(81)
Kevin Morby - Oh My God
Kevin Morby
Oh My God
LP
79
critic score
(20)
72
user score
(185)
Strand of Oaks - Eraserland
Strand of Oaks
Eraserland
LP
74
critic score
(11)
72
user score
(61)
Durand Jones & The Indications - American Love Call
Durand Jones & The Indications
American Love Call
LP
77
critic score
(10)
76
user score
(280)
Phoebe Bridgers - Christmas Song
Phoebe Bridgers
Christmas Song
Holiday
76
user score
(3)
Ryley Walker - The Lillywhite Sessions
Ryley Walker
The Lillywhite Sessions
LP
70
critic score
(10)
78
user score
(8)
Phosphorescent - C'est La Vie
Phosphorescent
C'est La Vie
LP
76
critic score
(23)
71
user score
(94)
Mitski - Be the Cowboy
Mitski
Be the Cowboy
LP
86
critic score
(38)
80
user score
(1,760)
LUMP - LUMP
LUMP
LUMP
LP
79
critic score
(26)
74
user score
(206)
Ryley Walker - Deafman Glance
Ryley Walker
Deafman Glance
LP
74
critic score
(15)
72
user score
(56)
A Place To Bury Strangers - Pinned
A Place To Bury Strangers
Pinned
LP
63
critic score
(13)
64
user score
(66)
Marlon Williams - Make Way for Love
Marlon Williams
Make Way for Love
LP
79
critic score
(14)
73
user score
(69)
Khruangbin - Con Todo El Mundo
Khruangbin
Con Todo El Mundo
LP
80
critic score
(10)
76
user score
(243)
Strand of Oaks - Harder Love
Strand of Oaks
Harder Love
Compilation
57
user score
(6)
shame - Songs of Praise
shame
Songs of Praise
LP
83
critic score
(24)
76
user score
(701)
Tom Rogerson & Brian Eno - Finding Shore
Tom Rogerson & Brian Eno
Finding Shore
LP
73
critic score
(12)
70
user score
(38)
Alex Lahey - I Love You Like a Brother
Alex Lahey
I Love You Like a Brother
LP
80
critic score
(8)
76
user score
(58)
Phoebe Bridgers - Stranger in the Alps
Phoebe Bridgers
Stranger in the Alps
LP
81
critic score
(15)
82
user score
(1,133)
Japanese Breakfast - Soft Sounds From Another Planet
Japanese Breakfast
Soft Sounds From Another Planet
LP
79
critic score
(25)
78
user score
(634)
Kane Strang - Two Hearts and No Brain
Kane Strang
Two Hearts and No Brain
LP
67
critic score
(3)
73
user score
(8)
Kevin Morby - City Music
Kevin Morby
City Music
LP
78
critic score
(21)
77
user score
(194)
Slowdive - Slowdive
Slowdive
Slowdive
LP
82
critic score
(34)
81
user score
(1,110)
Bleached - Can You Deal?
Bleached
Can You Deal?
EP
80
critic score
(3)
71
user score
(12)
Strand of Oaks - Hard Love
Strand of Oaks
Hard Love
LP
68
critic score
(12)
69
user score
(42)
Ryley Walker - Golden Sings That Have Been Sung
Ryley Walker
Golden Sings That Have Been Sung
LP
79
critic score
(17)
74
user score
(38)