AOTY 2023
Joji - SMITHEREENS
Nov 4, 2022 (updated Nov 5, 2022)
52
Joji releases his best single possibly ever with Glimpse of US, then decides he hates himself and his audience so he drops a 24 minute album with 8 minutes of material. This thing is embarrassing. This should not have come out. It is barely finished. I can't imagine thinking so little of your audience that you would give them this second disk of demo garbage, and call it an album

Watch people call this trash "experimental" and "deep". My god, stop letting him get away with the bare minimum PLEASE

Edit: LOOOOOOL just let me vent!!! I don’t care if you love this. God damn you people have no sense of humor.

168 Comments
1y
one of your worst takes yet
1y
If this is the bare minimum then I must be really easy to please.
1y
uh oh
1y
bradley just a hater
1y
based take
1y
Mfw Joji has an unorthodox album format (it's an insult to albums)
1y
goddamn brad, i respect your opinion but I disagree almost entirely
1y
1AM freestyle 30/100 lmaaaaooooo
1y
if this album had a clout baddies promo you would've given it a 10
1y
Another L take from Brad's bad taste in music. -__-
1y
Huge L omg
1y
You make me want to cry. That’s (in my opinion) kind of cruel. But even so, I do respect YOUR opinion.
1y
holy L lmaooooo
1y
big L
1y
Sure it feels a little underdeveloped, but it isn't THAT bad
1y
just making sure i don't fit in: the review
1y
😬😬😬 respect but L
1y
"Watch people call this experimental and deep but not me, because my IQ is very high and you do need a high IQ like mine to have my perfect and factual understanding of what good music sounds like"
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
1y
Couldn't agree more tbh. W y'all just driding some average
1y
Sorry but this is thought too simply. A review of your review written by you would probably be: "This should not have come out. It is barely finished". It doesn't matter if the album is deliberately profound or not. I think it's coincidence, but work and author are always to be separated and I'm afraid you forgot that.
1y
brad i like you but what the fuck is this take
1y
You’re right, it’s such a disappointment because the singles had me excited. It’s a messy project that imo doesn’t even have that low of lows, it is just so poorly thrown together that the sum of its parts is embarrassing.
1y
unnecessary disrespectful for no reason
1y
It's totally fine to like or not like whatever, but when you talk about something that you don't like in such a superior way like other people are wrong for liking it, then it goes beyond just "giving your opinion", at that point you're just disrespectful for no reason.
1y
Bradley being a disrespectful cunt towards an artist and his fanbase just cause he didn't like the album? OK but what's new.
1y
No I agree with this one
1y
brad dont be a pretentious twat challenge
1y
what a terrible take
1y
Oh cool! Brad is live what is the event? oh... nevermind, see ya saturday man! :D
1y
big L
1y
I... AgreeπŸ‘
1y
Exactly. This album is absolutely the bare minimum. I wouldn’t be surprised if the user scores plummet after the recency bias wears off.
1y
Nah, this album is a vibe and that's all it wants to be. Album feels great to listen to.
1y
What happened to subjectivity in music? Why attack a fanbase for simply liking music that you didn't like? Not everything was catered for you and not every piece of music has to be profound.
1y
I agree with Matheus. I don't believe that Brad is a music snob, but the last sentence made him sound like one
1y
I finished listening to it and forgot most of the tracks almost immediately. You're honestly right.
1y
huge L and attacking the fanbase too? disgrace for you to be at the top of this platform.
1y
^@carlos at least this guy is honest why he is upset. People are afraid I’m going to make other people hate this album. I really expected better from this album. I really do believe people will buy up halved baked demos and it will keep Joji from evolving.
1y
Sometimes I think Stalin was right
1y
@brad taste. I personally enjoyed this album, but i dont have a problem with you not liking the album, because thats your opinion, and i can respect ones opinion, but you attacked the fanbase, and after watching your review, didnt even give half the music a chance. You decided you didnt like it before it even started. Go in with a neutral point of view next time.
1y
common Brad L
1y
i fully agree with it being mid but brad. dude. this is really mean to the fanbase. you should be able to say you dont like it without insulting the ones who are fans of it. i hella respect you but this was a bit of an L
1y
Love how half the time your attitude is so toxic, you make me upset over albums that I don't even like
1y
I have never seen someone get this much flame because of a music opinion but I understand why cause this shit is fire
1y
Brad made people mad again :(
1y
Guys this is not fantano approved yet, so be patient. Let's just wait until it grows on him for exactly the amount of points that land on user score
1y
smh
1y
Professional Hater
1y
Ngl Brad this really gives the impression that you wrote this 'review' this way with the sole intention of pissing off a group of people and little more than that. It's nothing against your opinion on the album - some people aren't going to enjoy this project and that's fine - it's just a shame you chose to go about voicing your displeasure with it in the way that you have. It's disappointing cause I genuinely enjoy your reviews - but I think these comments show that I'm not alone in thinking that you've maybe gone a touch too far here. Nobody's asking you to change your opinion on the album at all, just be a bit less of a dick with your words sometime :)
1y
time for the score to drop
1y
Uh oh, Brad seems to have made people mad.

Meanwhile, Me, A Muse enjoyer: 😎
1y
AOTY users when they find an unpopular opinion from a popular AOTY figure:
1y
I disagree have a good day brad :)
1y
Stream burning barn
1y
stream paramore
1y
stream earl sweatshirt
1y
stream slipknot
1y
he is right tbh...
1y
Tf???? How can you dislike this so much???
1y
I don't usually agree with your Joji takes but Im gonna have to agree here you are totally right this thing is so underwhelming. I don't know how everyone is eating this up.
1y
@i3su No he is just completely right this time. Where's the substance in this project? It's just sloopy, poorly executed and has just demoish like quality to it
1y
horrible take
1y
It's always the same with Joji. He releases amazing singles (Glimpse Of Us, Run and Slow Dancing In The Dark were some of the spectacular singles he put out before his last releases) and the project as a whole ends up being a let down. This is specially true with this album, it sounds sooooo unfinished.
1y
music doesnt always have to be sum profound bs lad, sometimes its fine to take something face value
1y
Yeah cool bro thats not the point i agree music shouldnt be a dick measurin competition but this just feels unfinished and also i mean i would like to have something to hold onto lyrically but there's nothing here like that.
1y
I liked it.
1y
Y’all on his dick ngl
1y
Yet to see a positive review from Brad on literally anything
1y
@samsepiol you must not be familiar with him then
1y
[hidden]
1y
@weedjesus I will eat another -Bill S
1y
If there were two guys on the moon and one of them killed the other with a rock would that be fucked up or what?
1y
This is good though :(
1y
@samsepiol That's just dumb, he literally gave a positive review 2 days ago.
Secondly, this review was technically positive, as he gave it a 52
1y
I think you're being a little too harsh Brad, but I agree this is being a little overrated right now.
1y
[hidden]
1y
man called it trash then gave it an above average score
1y
hahahaha! You offended more people than Filthy Frank
1y
[hidden]
1y
The amount of energy people are putting into flaming Brad for this review is 20x more energy than Joji has ever put into his music lmao
1y
ok im done with this guy
1y
why are you suddenly getting disrespectful in all of your reviews
1y
didn't realise this was such a hot take damn
1y
I really like Brad's music reviews, but man, this take is just ass. Maybe his worst take?? idk man.
1y
Respect, but still an L take ngl
1y
just here for the ratio : ^ )
1y
Do the mario brad :)
1y
ok incel
1y
steam perpetual now by rRoxymore
1y
@Koltenb exactly
1y
Brad is just turning into a shitposter, because that's what gives him an audience and makes him money. But at the same time, he's losing his respect as an actual critic
1y
Brad's stupid ass going on a whole "it's just a joke" to save his skin, even tho there was nothing remotely comedic about his "review", he was just being an arrogant asshole.
1y
"save his skin" from what? what exactly am i saving myself from?
1y
yay 100 comments :)
1y
Holy shit, this has been the most divisive album I've seen throughout the month I've been on here.

I've love when an album has mixed opinions, makes me curious to check it for myself. I'm seeing different opinions on this, and I love how simulataneously positive & negative reactions are. That's what's fascinating about music.
1y
you guys are mad but he's completely valid. Nectar and Ballads 1 blow this album out of the water for me. Every song on here was boring and mid except Die for You and Glimpse of us. Everything else just sounds unfinished or like the most basic mainstream pop imaginable.
1y
@Zipping I'll admit YUKON is the only track on the 2nd half of this album that's the closest to feeling like a finished track
1y
honestly a pretty high score based on what you said in your review, but I agree. Pretty bad album and I'm shocked so many people are eating it up.
1y
who hurt u
1y
You basically saw that people were calling you out cause you were unecessarily mean towards the fans of the album and in order to minimize the outrage you did the old "haha guys I'm only joking", despite not saying anything comedic...
The point is that even if you don't like something, being a dick to the people that do is very immature. Saying that Joji hates his fanbase is silly since most of that fans seem fairly pleased.
1y
Based score tbh
1y
New comment section to sleep in πŸ›Œ
1y
At least it wasn’t bad rated at all and he gives based points on like the singles being as good as this 24 minutes should be its not that bad, its just decent and he has a point
1y
Brad is getting destroyed by these joji fans
1y
i like rats :) do you guys like rats?
1y
WHAT?? 🀨 A different O-o-o-OPINION?!?!? 😳😳 I can’t believe it! 😱😱😱 How can your rating be different than MINE!! 😑😑🀬🀬🀬 I’m so fucking mad for NO FUCKING REASON!! πŸ‘ΉπŸ’€πŸ‘Ή How can you say _ is bad 🀦‍♂️ BUT THEN SAY THIS IS GOOD??? πŸ€”πŸ€” It doesn’t make any sense 😡‍πŸ’«πŸ˜΅‍πŸ’« You should have my opinion πŸ‘ΏπŸ˜Ύ You can’t have your own opinion!! GRRRAAAAGGAGAGGGGHHH!!! πŸ‘ΊπŸ‘ΊπŸ‘ΊπŸ‘ΊπŸ‘ΊπŸ‘ΊπŸ‘ΊπŸ‘Ί
1y
rats are def an overhated animal imo. super funny and awesome my cat loves bringing them to me as a gift and i tell him thank you
1y
cant believe this mf pulled the "oh it's just a joke!!! you dont have humor!!!" card. annoying ass
1y
rats are pretty funny, I like rats :D
1y
Rate are annoying 😑
I like mice 🐭
1y
Mice are pretty annoying >:(
I like gerbils :)))
1y
Well, you're a piece of shit, not a critic. I'm surprised that anyone here listens to you at all. And stop making excuses, your review is at the level of the "Hating popular things doesn't make you an interesting person" meme. There is no humor here! Go find a job instead of writing a ton of useless text.
1y
Silly bakka silly ba
γ‚·γƒͺγ‚’γ‚Ήγͺshit, lemme shake it up
Do what I want, shit, gotta reckon ya
Got a thirst for the worst lookin' 馬鹿γͺ cheap-ass
Silly bakka silly ba
Silly ass looking shit, gotta shake it up
Wanna be lookin' freaks all they do is talk
Getcha head out ya ass like what you got, huh?
1y
I don't think it's 52/100 bad but still it's pretty average, respectable opinion. That being said I can't believe no one commenting how bad the album cover is though? Like it's begging people to think the project is lazy.
1y
we are talking about the guy who played filthy frank, what did you guys expect?
1y
Bro really struck a nerve with this one
1y
it's only got a 70 how is everyone mad
1y
"where the sense of humor" bro what in your review was funny or a joke lmao don't got to like the album but what the hell is the it's just a joke thing about
1y
this whole situation is always going to be one of the most confusing things to happen on this site
1y
big fucking L for you my boy
1y
Hands are red with your blame
Megaphone screaming my name
Whimpers someone I should've loved
Souls weeping above
I've seen
What you're doing to me
Destroying puppet strings to our souls
Micro waves me insane
A blade cuts in your brain
Sounds like forks on a plate
Blackboard scratched with hate
I've seen
What you're doing to me
Destroying puppet strings to our souls
1y
I feel ashamed to be apart of this community after reading these comments
1y
^^^^
1y
What the actual fuck is happening here? this is confusing
1y
brad taste in music smitheerens chat
1y
brad taste in music
1y
"sense of humor"? bro what part is funny
1y
Based
1y
Welcome to the mountaintop
Waitin' 'til the fight calls
I hope you're ready to be swingin' 'til the night falls
Are you a slave? An entertainer 'til the fun dies?
I hope you're ready to be swingin' 'til the sunrise
1y
Alright everyone, opinion on axolotls?
1y
they go HARD
1y
When someone else has a different opinion 😱😱😱
1y
Loving this thread 🍿
1y
@HenryThe12 love it and hate it at the same time.

Can't believe this is still going.
1y
How everyone is so mad 😭, it's not even worth the defense
1y
I agree...
1y
@HenryThe12 same bruh
1y
I respect Brad and I don't think this is a bad take but bro's kinda sounding like an asshole rn.
1y
Okay even though I don't agree with this review or it's messaging, this review did not deserve THIS MUCH discourse lmao. Took my a few days to realize that this was WAYY too much and blown way out of proportion
1y
I get u i hate how unfinished all of his music sounds because of his massive potential but damn this works very well here giving me the ooz by king krule vibes its sounds alien and unfinished and it shines for it i do hope joji comes out with a real big budget album that really capitalises on his potential fully but for now this works great too
1y
@Matt I agree. He technically gave it a positive score
1y
dead chat
1y
yeaa slay
1y
i had a very nice burger today, what's some burger places you guys recommend?
1y
@Pipe In-N-Out, Five Guys, Smashburger and Shake Shack!
1y
hey gyus if anyone wants to play BTD5 Mobile come to me and ill give you a game code
1y
No wonder he never gives negative reviews. People are absolutely livid he gave a majorly forgettable fart of an RnB album a 5/10 I'm sorry brah this is not cool 😭😭😭😭
1y
this review, from what i've seen, is generally percieved as a hot take but i understand ur perspective
1y
A huge fat L. It’s not amazing or anything but it’s not that bad either.
12mo
One sec I have to make this Brads most-commented review
12mo
Done
12mo
Joji fans were on some shit for this one.
11mo
[hidden]
11mo
@DollyBelle this album has a 64 how can this be considered a hot take anymore
11mo
yo ur right this album is ass lmao
10mo
@MUXA your only activity on this site is limited to two spiteful comments; its like your whole personality is trying to make people dislike you
skill issue
try being decent, yeah? who knows, you might get a follower or two 🀷
10mo
@surlace I know a dude who calls people “tasteless” because he likes Meghan Trainor and nobody else does
10mo
SUPER W
9mo
this is a Brad W, sorry joji fans
8mo
[hidden]
7mo
guys chill, Brad gave this 52 for 24mins, next time Joji comes back with a 40min album then its gonna be 100! #mathssavetheworld
7mo
the first time in my life i will EVER agree with brad. joji fans just got it bad.
5mo
He’s right but yeah he could’ve been lighter
4mo
In retrospect, man was SPITTING
Sign in to comment.
More Reviews by BradTasteMusic
Joji - Glimpse of Us
90
Jun 10, 2022
Joji - Nectar
62
Oct 1, 2020
Joji - Gimme Love
68
Apr 16, 2020
Joji - Run
89
Feb 6, 2020
Joji - Sanctuary
79
Oct 10, 2020
Joji - BALLADS 1
62
Oct 31, 2018
Advertisement
Rate and review albums along with the AOTY community. Create an account today.
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
More Reviews
MattsReviews
charcoal
ST4T1C
cfnugent
CamLikesMusic
Case
BaddieBaphomet
Host
CDTVProductions
Davibitt1234

November Playlist