AOTY 2018
charlie17
charlie17
The Bay Area
Kanye West - ye
Kanye West
ye
84
Oct 23

Recent Reviews

Nov 28, 2018
74
Not as good as it’s follow up, but still extremely solid. The beats are here, the lyrics are here, and it never outstays it’s welcome.

Best track: Dostoyevsky
Worst track: Making a murderer

Rating: 74/100(very good)
Nov 28, 2018
82
A near flawless Ep, with exceptional beats and exceptional rapping. Much like Daytona it doesn’t bring a ton new to the table in terms of production or flows, but what it does do, it does with extreme proficiency. Definitely a must listen.

Best tracks: long liveth, fentanyl
Worst tracks: n/a

Rating: 82/100(great)
Nov 28, 2018
42
Extremely hit or miss. While there are quite a few bangers here, as expected, roughly half of the tracks here are watered down Latin pop mistakes. 6ix9ine still can’t sing and his features aren’t much better. Can’t see myself returning outside of a few tracks.

Best tracks: Tati(thought this was on day 69 lol), Kanga(1 of 2 solid kanye features on this album, very playful beat)
Worst track: Fefe, Bebe, mama

Rating: 42/100(bad)
Nov 28, 2018*
26
Jaden makes an entire album without 1, count it, 1 enjoyable track! Like I can’t even laugh at this shit it’s that bad(except ten ten). It’s like if syre was stripped of its redeeming qualities, the production sucks, the lyrics are somehow worse than syre with none of the charisma of tracks like icon. Jaden’s influences are worn even more on his sleeve, so much so that whatever he had of a unique identity is completely gone and traded in for a poor brockhampton/Travis ... read more
Nov 28, 2018
46
God jid is so lame. This is somehow worse than the last one! He most definitely has potential, but he continually wastes it, with mediocre production and what feels to me as played out flows, as artists like earl sweatshirt and especially Vince Staples already fill JID’s attempted flow. Do better!
Dec 16, 2018
User is no longer with us
Nov 15, 2018
you inspire me to keep writing, please never stop doing reviews :)
Oct 15, 2018
102 followers, heck yeah!
About
I’m charlie17. I’m 16. I have a shit taste in music. And I like writing. Check out the shoutbox for my more "in-depth" reviews.
Rating system
100=personal classic
90-99=exceptional
80-89=great
70-79=good
60-69=alright
51-59=slightly better than average
50= complete indifference
40-49= slightly worse than average
30-39=bad
1-29= garbage
0=angelic 2 the core

([!] signifies best and/or worst track of whatever album is reviewed)
Around the Web
Rating Distribution
90-99
 
59

80-89
 
78

70-79
 
82

60-69
 
44

50-59
 
23

40-49
 
13

30-39
 
10

20-29
 
4

10-19
 
6

0-9
 
8


2018 Playlist
AOTY Discord
Forums
Vinyl Me, Please