AOTY's Most Overhated Albums of 2020

If you want to be included just comment below and I'll add you. Critic Scores usually suck so check out the user scores if you wanna see the popular opinion on the album.

Oliver Tree - Ugly is Beautiful
70
My pick
@BruhMan's pick
@Schmoobin's pick
@Noz's pick

Critic Score: 65
User Score: 62
Idles - Ultra Mono
70
My 2nd pick
@SMTCubes's pick
@RickSalix's pick

Critic Score: 77
User Score: 76
Lil Tjay - State of Emergency
66
My 3rd pick

Critic Score: 67
User Score: 48
The 1975 - Notes on a Conditional Form
35
@CLJesse's pick
@N0stalgia's pick
@AndreManfre93's pick
@Aoaystheory's pick

Critic Score: 71
User Score: 62
Dorian Electra - My Agenda
82
@Stankysauce's pick
@redbded's pick

Critic Score: 80
User Score: 72
Poppy - I Disagree
86
@spicyb's pick
@Allofasudden's pick

Critic Score: 69
User Score: 73
Fiona Apple - Fetch the Bolt Cutters
90
@redbded's 2nd pick
@hellodecatur's pick

Critic Score: 94
User Score: 84
Lil Darkie - THIS DOES NOT EXIST
53
@Basic_Garci's pick
@Tristan's pick
@M3GAWATT's pick
@HIVE's pick
@MattsReview's pick
@Rater's pick
@Kal3n's pick
@Noz's 2nd pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 61
AJJ - Good Luck Everybody
34
@Toasterqueen12's pick

Critic Score: 70
User Score: 56
The Killers - Imploding the Mirage
@marvelgaryen's pick
@cakenator's pick

Critic Score: 75
User Score: 67
Gunna - WUNNA
70
@DoubleZ's pick
@pizzagrande's pick
@TomBejoy's pick
@gopxity's pick

Critic Score: 62
User Score: 49
Childish Gambino - 3.15.20
54
@Nightwing734's pick
@JAZZYCHIEF's pick
@JayCrackers's pick
@HIVE's 2nd pick
@Doofly's pick
@MasterCrackfox's pick
@EnigmaticSnob's pick
@HoodieBraden's pick

Critic Score: 79
User Score: 66
U.S. Girls - Heavy Light
@hellodecatur's 2nd pick

Critic Score: 80
User Score: 69
LOONA - 12:00
61
@Flamingooooo's pick

Critic Score: 80
User Score: 70
Glass Animals - Dreamland
29
@ConcreteCastles's pick
@elitimesfour's pick

Critic Score: 75
User Score: 58
Spillage Village - Spilligion
64
@Phillip's pick

Critic Score: 65
User Score: 71
Joyner Lucas - ADHD
32
@Muratka's pick

Critic Score: 56
User Score: 33
Joji - Nectar
70
@MattsReviews's 2nd pick
@TreyLikesBands's pick
@thamostonres's pick
@notanalt's pick

Critic Score: 67
User Score: 70
Tame Impala - The Slow Rush
58
@Stankysauce's 2nd pick
@ParthanyJobtano's pick
@RakkSmells's pick
@MikeOwen's pick
@Pickle's pick
@LasagnaZissou's pick

Critic Score: 78
User Score: 74
AC/DC - Power Up
32
@JustSomeGuy's pick

Critic Score: 76
User Score: 46
Car Seat Headrest - Making A Door Less Open
54
@Dabzilla's pick
@znorth3's pick
@TomBejoy's 2nd pick

Critic Score: 73
User Score: 65
Drake - Dark Lane Demo Tapes
70
@AZIZ's pick

Critic Score: 50
User Score: 54
Royce da 5'9'' - The Allegory
70
@LyricalMiracleS's pick

Critic Score: 76
User Score: 67
100 gecs - 1000 gecs and the Tree of Clues
68
@SMTCubes's 2nd pick
@nielsensratings's pick

Critic Score: 78
User Score: 67
Lauv - ~how i'm feeling~
@andiov1's pick

Critic Score: 74
User Score: 57
Eminem - Music To Be Murdered By
70
@Scre4meh's pick
@Tristan's 2nd pick
@vvvpavlic's pick
@Getoutdakitchen's pick

Critic Score: 63
User Score: 46
Code Orange - Underneath
70
@jragrazal's pick

Critic Score: 84
User Score: 75
Four Year Strong - Brain Pain
@BGL13's pick

Critic Score: 80
User Score: 65
Trippie Redd - Pegasus
25
@PASS_THE_AUX's pick
@oscarepic's pick

Critic Score: 42
User Score: 32
Dance Gavin Dance - Afterburner
@PASS_THE_AUX's 2nd pick

Critic Score: 60
User Score: 56
Ryan Benis - Rollercoaster
32
@HIVE's 3rd pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 63
Dua Lipa & The Blessed Madonna - Club Future Nostalgia
@MikeOwen's 2nd pick
@Bruhman's 2nd pick

Critic Score: 73
User Score: 54
Justin Bieber - Changes
27
@realrealweasel's pick
@oh's pick
@Maqtheus's pick

Critic Score: 55
User Score: 28
BLACKPINK - The Album
53
@eliiscool5's pick

Critic Score: 68
User Score: 52
Duki - 24
46
@elextranodpl's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 59
NIKI - Moonchild
70
@TomBejoy's 3rd pick

Critic Score: 50
User Score: 66
The Kid LAROI - FUCK LOVE (SAVAGE)
@Cry's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 46
NAV - Good Intentions
40
@Dombot's pick

Critic Score: 49
User Score: 40
Nas - King's Disease
70
@ka1's pick

Critic Score: 74
User Score: 71
Future - High Off Life
70
@ka1's 2nd pick

Critic Score: 62
User Score: 62
Sega Bodega - Salvador
@nicoperagine's pick
@seasonal's pick

Critic Score: 69
User Score: 66
Grimes - Miss Anthropocene
@Inglume's pick
@FoxInTheCity's pick
@redbded's 3rd pick

Critic Score: 75
User Score: 74
NAV - Emergency Tsunami
30
@GayCunt69's pick
@BruhPablo's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 42
Public Enemy - What You Gonna Do When The Grid Goes Down?
@tha138's pick

Critic Score: 75
User Score: 63
YoungBoy Never Broke Again - Top
24
@nijakiler17's pick

Critic Score: 71
User Score: 33
Russ - Shake the Snow Globe
36
@blinkAndMissit's pick

Critic Score: 86
User Score: 43
Green Day - Father of All...
22
@Docky's pick
@AnalVape's pick

Critic Score: 59
User Score: 29
Królówczana Smuga - ODRAPDORAP
@Frippotronic's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 73
Jockstrap - Wicked City
70
@okcomputer12127's pick

Critic Score: 80
User Score: 76
1
2
Comments
Sign in to comment
1mo
eternal atake 2nd pick
1mo
3.15.20
2mo
@cakenator Added!
2mo
I need to see more POSHBOY2 slander
2mo
I would have to say imploding the mirage
2mo
@_uddipta15 no problem, I added it
2mo
@Chode oh sorry didn't notice that. Moral Panic by Nothing But Thieves comes to mind.
2mo
@_uddipta15 Didn't see this until now, but what SMT said. You got any for 2020?
2mo
@_uddipta15 nah, it's just that this is pretty much for 2020 albums
2mo
I think @_uddipta15 may have missed the concept.
2mo
SOUTHSIDE by Sam Hunt, it's a decent album, I give it a 7 out of 10. I think it's overhated, Rolling Stone 7/10, Pitchfork 7.5/10, RC A- (91/100), and also listed as honorable mention in best albums of 2020 with 12 ponts now.
2mo
SOUTHSIDE by Sam Hunt, it's a decent album, I give it a 7 out of 10. I think it's overhated, Rolling Stone 7/10, Pitchfork 7.5/10, RC A- (91/100), and also listed as honorable mention in best albums of 2020 with 12 ponts now.
2mo
@redbded nah it's fine, i added it
2mo
Sorry to add another but I think recently it has been the most releveant. You can remove one of my others if you want, just put this one in. Nightmare Vacation
3mo
Why did anyone pick FTBC?
3mo
This must've taken so much time to make! Congrats!
3mo
@A1t3rTheFreak @redbded Added!
3mo
I'd probably say Halsey's Manic
like yeah it ain't the best thing ever but it is such an improvement from her

people give Joji a pass for the same reason but somehow i guess other artists don't get the same treatment?
3mo
I have another pick, and it would probably be the new Grimes album
3mo
@MusicGod added
3mo
F*CK LOVE-The Kid LAROI please. Thanks!
3mo
@seasonal Added!
3mo
Gonna say Sega Bodega's Salvador was the most overhated. If I can add a few more, I'd say Yaeji's WHAT WE DREW and Zebra Katz's LESS IS MOOR
3mo
most of these are still pretty bad not going to lie
3mo
@Edgeworth added!
3mo
In my opinion, I think it's safe to say Biffy Clyro's A Celebration of Endings was severely overhated from users.
If I throw in a few more, I'd say All Time Low's Wake Up Sunshine, Creeper's Sex, Death & the Infinite Void and Nothing But Thieves' Moral Panic have harsh scores from users.
3mo
@Quet added
3mo
Also…
Hey u x was given quite undeserving lukewarm reception by users.
MAGDALENE is unnecessarily polarized.
3mo
ALICIA - Alicia Keys. Sorta disappointing coming from Alicia Keys, but it’s a pretty fun listen nonetheless (also HERE is worse)
3mo
You brought 24's score down even more D: Still great list!
3mo
also lil uzi vert vs the world 2
3mo
add making a door less open, no pressure and wunna
3mo
pick* lol
3mo
The Slow Rush is a really good pic, didn't think of that
3mo
@Pickle added
3mo
Honestly the slow rush
3mo
@BGL13 you've been added
3mo
brain pain- four year strong
3mo
@Toasterqueen12 tbh I've seen a bunch of people be a contrarian about it
3mo
@Toasterqueen12 it was in the oven fir too long
3mo
How tf is fetch the bolt cutters "overheated." It's at an 84!!
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement
Likes (40)
halbery
elitimesfour
TeodoreMcgee
patricia4221
Barelydead
A1t3rTheFreak
Slush_Puppy
Doofy
gopxity
AndrewK
Advertisement

February 2021 Playlist
Forums