Different album. I can understand why at the time people didn’t receive the album well. Almost 13 years later it gets a “must hear” on it, should be rated higher in my opinion - experimental in a good way
Favorite songs: black skinhead, new slaves, I’m in it
Worst: send it up

Pretty fun album i can’t lie, but honestly most of the songs did not really stick with me
Favorite songs: the race, I <3 my choppa
Worst: Saran pack

Definitely not as good as the first single but still not bad, I still have hope that the album will be great 🙏

Pretty good song I’m hyped for the album 🔥

Great vocals, the highs are definitely high but sometimes it gets boring, some of the second half of the album
Favorite songs: how many years, far away, Louie bag
Worst: one more smile

Didn’t add much so it’s a disappointing deluxe with some good songs
Favorite: fomdj

Such a smooth album, and the production just feels so smooth - everything blends together better than the first one
Favorite songs: mar-a-lago, skinny suge II, gold feet
Worst: none

Pretty good album and also one of the best jazz rap albums I’ve heard
Favorite songs: look at me, Frank Lucas, baby $hit
Worst: Scottie beam

Good soundtrack 👍 just not super for me
Favorite song: house
Worst: altars

I mean not super special, and there’s no experimenting just same old Brent but it works good as an album
Favorite songs: butterflies, wrong faces, pure fantasy
Worst: other side

Truly a classic and one of the best ye albums OAT no song is a miss and Kanye is practically at his best
Favorite songs: gorgeous, so appalled, hell of a life
Worst: who will survive in America

Good album as a whole just not many songs I would come back to
Favorite songs: root of all evil, sign of the times
Worst: call on me

Not good not bad but a pbm ep, idk what to say but yeah
Favorite songs: glacier, party, meanstreet
Worst: nodrank

A great album from Carti so much so that I wish he went back to music like this sometimes
Favorite songs: lean 4 real, long time, foreign
Worst: home

Great album, different album which I like there is a reason this is a must listen album - because it is a must listen album
Favorite songs: die hard, count me out, silent hill
Worst: crown

Gets so much hate but I find it decent, Kanye isn’t at his best which drops this heavily. I won’t even bother reviewing the second one for now bc it’s quite a bit worse
Favorite songs: stars, paid, paperwork
Worst: hoodrat

You can feel the emotion and nino paid as an artist is solid.. but the thing is, not much replay value on this album still a decent one that has some gems
Favorite songs: Joey story, progress report, play this at my funeral
Worst: weekend in paris

Rose is top tier.. but the rest not so much
Favorite songs: rose, fallen, laylow
Worst: most of them

Smooth album just not super memorable for me so it deserves a 67
Favorite songs: I’ll take care of you, sugar on my tongue
Worst: stop playing with me

Listened to it in September when it came out… have not added one song to a playlist and haven’t listened to ONE song since it came out. Genuine disappointment crazy album cover too