ID ranked(cause why not)

With them self producing, ID has never come off so clear in their vision.

Best: The Fall, Hopeless Opus

While bloated with excess weight, I don't mind. Easily their best since S+M

Best: Sirens, I Wish

The only unofficial album on this list, these tracks reflect the best of EP era ID
Best: Home, Starlight

Excellent debut with some excellent storytelling sprinkled throughout
Best: Curse, I Need a Minute

Would've been the better debut album; but then again, we wouldn't have tiptoe
Best: Amsterdam, Pantomime

Classic alt rock with the sometimes obnoxious(but always charming) synths.
Best: Emma, Hear Me

Rick Rubin as executive producer brings some order to the chaos, but MA1 perseveres to be hit or miss(more often hit)
Best: My Life, Dull Knives

Diet soda equivalent of the It's Time EP, but tiptoe makes up for everything
Best: Tiptoe, Nothing Left to Say//Rocks

Better evolve, with more emotion, but still a step down from S+M and NV before it.
Best: Burn Out, Cool Out

a collection of demos from 10+ years ago that I have a bit of a soft spot for
Best: Destroyed, Woke

Mattman and Robin can be decent producers, but they are toxic when it comes to lyrics(and they clearly kidnapped the guitar)
Best: In Your Corner, Fire In These Hills

The last third of this album was never meant to be released, someone in the studio just tripped and plopped these on last second.
Best: Mouth of The River, I Don't Know Why