these are the same cover

for when album covers are different ... but they're the same

i try to keep the list to only include covers that are coincidentally the same - there are plenty of homages to other albums or parodies of other albums that aren't included here because that's cheating. you're trying to make the same cover. what's REALLY cool and interesting are when 2 different creative ideas end up converging on mostly the same end product. when the covers are different ... but they're the same

Amnesia Scanner - Another Life
lots of limbs and bodies actin weird
Ground-Zero - Consume Red
90
lots of limbs and bodies actin weird
Swans - Filth
40
teef in the middle
Injury Reserve - Floss
80
teef in the middle (shiny)
N.E.R.D - No_One Ever Really Dies
teef in the middle (shiny)
Tangerine Dream - Zeit
80
X. circle moment (the creator)
Placebo - Battle For The Sun
XII. circle moment (the blessed) (thanks @Notorious_Man)
Bauhaus - The Sky's Gone Out
XIII. circle moment (the goth) (thank u MinatoArisato)
Architects - All Our Gods Have Abandoned Us
XIV. circle moment (the wildcard) (thank u ARIDOTJPEG)
Deakin - Sleep Cycle
60
hazy blurry purple environment
Julia Holter - Loud City Song
85
hazy blurry purple environment
Earth - Earth 2: Special Low Frequency Version
80
big sky landscape with white top
Duster - Stratosphere
85
big sky landscape with white top
Weyes Blood - Titanic Rising
60
woman floatin in a dimly lit environment with beams of light
Allie X - Cape God
woman floatin in a dimly lit environment with beams of light
Hozier - Wasteland, Baby!
MAN floatin in a dimly lit environment with beams of light (thank u @Louis13)
The Leonard Simpson Duo - LSD
60
repeated colorful square pattern
Guerilla Toss - GT ULTRA
75
repeated colorful square pattern
Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
65
rectangle with white border (thank u @xanderjones)
Death Grips - Niggas on the Moon
85
rectangle with white border (thank u @xanderjones)
Kero Kero Bonito - Time 'n' Place
85
rectangle with [REDACTED] color border
Navy Blue - Àdá Irin
65
rectangle with [REDACTED] color border
30
not even the same fucking shape as the others why did i ever add it to the list (for publicity, stupid!)
Radiohead - Kid A
80
clusterfuck on the bottom, pretty sky on the top
Father John Misty - Pure Comedy
clusterfuck on the bottom, pretty sky on the top
Lightning Bolt - Wonderful Rainbow
70
clusterfuck on the bottom, pretty sky on the top
Comus - First Utterance
85
white background, black art coming in from the left side
Massive Attack - Mezzanine
white background, black art coming in from the left side
Flying Lotus - Los Angeles
white background, black art coming in from the left side (but not as far this time)
Prurient - Frozen Niagara Falls
60
white background, black art coming in from the left side (but not as far this time)
青葉市子 [Ichiko Aoba] - 0
85
pink (also they both have a score of 87 and i think that's neat)
Merzbow - Scumtron
pink (great now this list is out of order) (thank u @bRUH54)
Earl Sweatshirt - solace
pink (also they both have a score of 87 and i think that's neat)
Sunny Day Real Estate - LP2
pink (doesnt have 87 score :( ) (thank u @notbuzzzila)
King Crimson - Islands
stars n space but with white in the center
Swans - My Father Will Guide Me Up a Rope to the Sky
70
stars n space but with white in the center
Joy Division - Unknown Pleasures
60
black with the wiggly white lines
Vince Staples - Summertime '06
black with the wiggly white lines
Full of Hell & Merzbow - Sister Fawn
black with the wiggly white lines
Rapsody - Laila's Wisdom
black background + woman + flower ring
Comments
Sign in to comment
1d
Duster- Self titled
Wilco- Star Wars
5d
Ivory - Omar Apollo and Set my Heart on Fire immediately - Perume Genius
1w
WE - Arcade Fire and Scott 3 - Scott Walker.
Big ole eye
1w
Add Atrocity Exhibition to that half n half colorful faces bit.
1mo
"The Life of Pi'erre 5" by Pi'erre Bourne and "IDK & FRIENDS :)" by IDK. both are just a straight-faced dude throwing up hand signs and looking up at the camera with his plushes
1mo
is the freddie / teddy one just an exception to the homage rule because that one seems painfully obvious
1mo
Swans - To Be Kind
Daniels gone - Broken Moose
1mo
Add Aesop Rock - Float to the Amnesiac, Leaving Your Body Map, Transa collection
1mo
Nujabes - Free Soul Nujabes First Collection
Also fits under rosy pastel clouds
1mo
The La's - The La's
Mr. Bungle - Disco Volante
1mo
modal soul by nujabes for the amnesiac section
1mo
Metro Boomin's HEROES AND VILLAINS goes with the WYWH cover
2mo
cLOUDDEAD - cLOUDDEAD
My Cat's A Stargazer - Monod Kinetics
Turnstile - Glow On

Colourful clouds, with no other objects in the scene
2mo
“Songs About My Cats” and “WLFGRL” are kinda similar: Closeup pic of an animal from dark in pale green colors
2mo
Don't know if this has been submitted yet, but these are practically the same cover. I'd be surprised if these weren't from the same designer.

Basement Jaxx "Scars": https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/874-basement-jaxx-scars.php
Galantis "The Aviary": https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/85077-galantis-the-aviary.php

Tbf you could pick any Galantis LP, but this one stands out more
2mo
you could add heros and villains to the area with the wish you were here one
3mo
I mean big ass dog mouth and pale green foliage respectively
3mo
Albert Hammond Jr's "AHJ" and Avantdale Bowling Club's "Trees" can fit next to "Circle of Veins" and "Sadness"
3mo
the thing sound track and "buy muy drugs" are similar to that injury reserve album cover
3mo
We should have a new category for "Rectangular image at the bottom, in a white space, with text on top", with Closer (Joy Division) (https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/4218-joy-division-closer.php), and Choosing (Sophie Jamieson) (https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/537252-sophie-jamieson-choosing.php)
3mo
the black and red one matches with float by aesop rock
3mo
@riskr I WILL NEVER RECOVER FROM THIS :(
3mo
niether of them have an 87 score anymore :sob:
3mo
There about 5 different weezer albums that could go here (band standing side by side with a solid color background and band logo above them)
3mo
That Fishmans album (https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/53597-fishmans-981228-otokotachi-no-wakare.php) has to be with "Electric Ladyland" and "I Got Dem 'Ol Kozmic Blues Again Mama!"
4mo
Two ones I always think of are both No.4 by STP and Blackstar by Bowie, and also Exile on main street by The Rolling stones and Achtung baby by U2 I get confused with also.
4mo
Shouldn't Presence by led zeppelin be with Wish you were here and Fellas on the Moon?
4mo
Everything Everything's Get to Heaven has the same gradient as well with kids see ghosts and emergency & I
4mo
Shouldn't cosmograma be with the circle group?
4mo
also TLOP4 (Pierre Bourne) and Cherry (Daphni) maybe?
4mo
idk if you think it's similar enough but Dance Fever by Florence + The machine kinda works for 'black background + woman + flower ring'
4mo
Is 4 Lovers by Death From Above for 'age-worn polaroid with WARM ASS lighting'
4mo
updated ✨💗🤩 thanks for all the circles
4mo
Tangerine dream, Placebo and Slauson Malon also look like "All out gods have abandoned us" by Architects. Almost the same as the other three but this time with a while background.
4mo
The Sky's Gone Out by Bauhaus is a circle moment
5mo
Got another submission! Hopefully this is a good one :)

Counterparts - You're Not You Anymore - https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/90315-counterparts-youre-not-you-anymore.php
Midwife - Like Author, Like Daughter - https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/82954-midwife-like-author-like-daughter.php
5mo
"Kamikaze" by Eminem and "Licensed to Ill" to the Beastie Boys if you haven't yet :)
5mo
Renja and Sanjam - Sacrifice works for "wiggly". Royal Blood - Self-titled and Gojira - Magma are also similar.
5mo
Arctic monkey's humbug could work for the age worn polaroid
5mo
Merzbow - Scumtron for the pink category
5mo
Kid Cudi - Entergalactic and The Kid Laroi - F*CK LOVE might be a good one too :)
5mo
Pierre Bourne - The Life of Pierre 4 is another solid color one
5mo
in my opinion you should add the new avantdale bowling club record to the pale green foliage category
5mo
updated 💗💽🏟️🔆🛖🛣️
5mo
crazy
5mo
This Ascension and The Shroud are two Ethereal Wave bands with album covers of women drowning in blue water
6mo
This is the best list on this website
7mo
just came across this https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/12355-alcest-shelter.php

for the "blue background with shiny head figure" one
7mo
Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here (https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/4215-pink-floyd-wish-you-were-here.php) and The Powers That B disc 1 - Death Grips (https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/16595-death-grips-niggas-on-the-moon.php). They have the exact amount of white surrounding the image in the centre.
8mo
@lexa oh snap, I just noticed mine was added. Awesome!!
8mo
@lexa You know what I can't argue with that. It is gorgeous and a clever homage. Plus it's your list so I respect all decisions made. It's just something I noticed so I pointed it out.

Also I got one last suggestion since I just noticed one and one is a recent album even.

The whole color, style, border and positioning of:
"I Told Bessie" by Elucid
And
"I'm Like A Virgin Losing A Child" by Manchester Orchestra

https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/508071-elucid-i-told-bessie.php

https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/8788-manchester-orchestra-im-like-a-virgin-losing-a-child.php
8mo
@Andrei i'll allow it
8mo
@KaneSeatHeadres i know i just wanted to throw one in there as the exception to prove the rule. plus its a gorgeous cover so how could i not
8mo
Dour Candy by billy woods
And
Downtown Battle Mountain by Dance Gavin Dance

Both are cityscapes with skyscrapers with a lack of color and to top it off both of them have an old timer flying mechanism in the sky.

https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/8982-billy-woods-dour-candy.php

https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/79833-dance-gavin-dance-downtown-battle-mountain.php
8mo
Btw the Freddie Gibbs one is a pretty obviously an homage which is against the idea of this list. Even Freddie is just a play on the name Teddy.
8mo
I love the idea of parallel thinking. Amazing list.
8mo
that typewriter one is so good
8mo
It doesn't have the title on the sign but the twin peaks soundtrack is similar to the last two
8mo
updated 👍💚
8mo
Kyuss - Welcome to Sky Valley x Acid King - Busse Woods have the same template in that there's a sign of the place the albums are based on on the right, & then the landscape.

https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/5835-kyuss-welcome-to-sky-valley.php
https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/21073-acid-king-busse-woods.php
9mo
faith by george michael and grace by jeff buckley have men looking in the same direction
9mo
Also White Light/ White Heat by The Velvet Underground
Self-titled by Metallica

(Black background with dark grey drawing in the corner)
9mo
Four Tet - There is love in you
Pink Floyd - Obscured by Clouds

(Black background covered by white and coloured circles)
10mo
@TipoOpositivo wow that's perfect thank u
10mo
Man on the Moon III: The Chosen by Kid Cudi and Realidade, Vida e Fé by Pense
10mo
Turn on the bright lights is literally the amnesiac cover a year later
10mo
thank u everyone for these great submissions 🤍 keeps me goin
11mo
I laughed a lot with 'swag baby'
11mo
fav list
11mo
try Nick Drake's Bryter Layter and Boris' Akuma no Uta
11mo
100th like because this list deserves it
11mo
Ayyy you could also compare that Navy Blue record with MGMT's Little Dark Age, they're pretty similar but in different colors!
11mo
Love this list, a suggestion:
Zayn - Mind of Mine
Lil Wayne - Tha Carter III

(Their names rhythm as well hehe)
11mo
Amazing list
11mo
I really like this! This was really fun to scroll through.
1y
finally got around to adding some of these suggestions 😇
1y
N.E.R.D and MBDTF are Ls, come on, now you only need to post single covers and point out they are the same as the LP
1y
Stain Licker by Imagine Drowning and You Wont Get What You Want by Daughters
1y
high as hope and sour !!!
1y
For Nurture, there is a band called Galileo galilei, and their 2013 album "ALARMS" has an almost identical album cover

https://open.spotify.com/album/2vpYs1TWH8FTvheTtZPTaq?si=8ObRlXTrS9SHT0YiRGOJ8Q
1y
this one might be a stretch, but "Lil Darkie Classics", "Clover" by Or3o, and the Cuphead Soundtrack all have 1920s-esque characters on the cover...
1y
A bit late but; Yeezus; Beerbongs & Bentleys; and ROADRUNNER: NEW LIGHT, NEW MACHINE
1y
The big spiral thing is also on Turn Blue by the Black Keys
1y
idk if youre taking suggestions, but 4 by car seat headrest and humbug by arctic monkeys look VERY similar
1y
lol this is super cool
1y
'Sempiternal' by Bring Me the Horizon and 'A Head Full of Dreams' by Coldplay both feature the geometric flower of life as the centerpiece of the cover art.
2y
7 by lil nas and bandana by freddie gibbs
2y
@Bjartolini good call
2y
suggestion: inner song and lianne la havas
2y
this is a VERY good list
2y
this is actually a really cool idea
2y
The Bad Touch (Bloodhound Gang) and Animals (Nickelback)
2y
Let it Be (The Beatles) & Demon Days (Gorillaz)
2y
Dancing for mental health & true romantic.
2y
this is my favorite list on AOTY
2y
0 now has an 86 score 😔
2y
For the circle add Placebo's Battle For The Sun
2y
How about Mac Demarco's 2 and Bruce Springsteen's The River?
2y
Cenizas and Slowdive
2y
suggestion
cenizas nicolas jaar and slowdive album
2y
the duster/earth one 🔥
2y
last one didn’t need a caption because of how apparent it is
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Likes (179)
JesusChrist
RafaelNoCritica
pprinter
lincoln
strawberry_AXOL
Alexaminations
ShoegazeJake
aaaaarryyaaaann
jaz_4
Fjuan
Advertisement

March Playlist