AOTY User's Most Underrated Album of All Time

I asked some users on this site what they believe is the most underrated album of all time. Here are the results.

Kid Cudi - Speedin' Bullet 2 Heaven
5
Toasterqueen12, DevinONeill and elitimesfour's pick

Critic Score: 42
User Score: 30
Kiss Kiss - Reality Vs. the Optimist
joshxxi and MrA's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 81
Radiohead - Amnesiac
85
SirTristan's pick

Critic Score: 77
User Score: 82
Moses Sumney - Aromanticism
80
louisomahoney’s pick

Critic Score: 81
User Score: 79
Cigarettes After Sex - Cry
SakuraFroster's pick

Critic Score: 67
User Score: 60
Mos Def - Black on Both Sides
95
aadeel's pick

Critic Score: 92
User Score: 87
Sun Kil Moon - April
jaronmeister's pick

Critic Score: 78
user Score: 79
Bon Jovi - These Days
Docky's pick

Critic Score: 45
User Score: 64
Les Rallizes Dénudés - '77 Live
ThrowBackGmac's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 85
Camp Lo - Uptown Saturday Night
90
squelch's pick

Critic Score: 86
User Score: 78
Common - Be
95
BruhMan's pick

Critic Score: 81
User Score: 85
Modest Mouse - The Lonesome Crowded West
Flamingooooo's pick

Critic Score: 86
User Score: 88
Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Brain Salad Surgery
TreyLikesBands' pick

Critic Score: 90
User Score: 80
FLUX Quartet - Feldman Edition 6: String Quartet No. 2
okcomputer12127's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 96
Modern English - Mesh & Lace
CLJesse's pick

Critic Score: 60
User Score: 79
Sematary & Ghost Mountain - HUNDRED ACRE WRIST HOSTED BY DJ SORROW
Stankysauce's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 82
SebastiAn - Total
Malneezy's pick

Critic Score: 74
User Score: 79
The World Is a Beautiful Place and I Am No Longer Afraid to Die - Whenever, If Ever
n o s t a l g i a's pick

Critic Score: 78
User Score: 78
Five Deez - Koolmotor
AZIZ's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 82
Aphex Twin - drukQs
andiov's pick

Critic Score: 63
User Score: 81
Violent Femmes - Hallowed Ground
JayCracker's pick

Critic Score: 65
User Score: 72
Tim Hecker - Virgins
80
ConcreteCastles' pick

Critic Score: 84
User Score: 84
Oceansize - Effloresce
Jamobo's pick

Critic Score: 72
User Score: 82
GDP - Useless Eaters
Space Vacation's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 75
Joni Mitchell - Hejira
jkpyg's pick

Critic Score: 73
User Score: 84
Fish Narc - WiLDFiRE
Basic_Garci's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 80
Merzbow - Pulse Demon
oh's pick

Critic Score: 69
User Score: 47
Paramore - After Laughter
Schmedess' pick

Critic Score: 84
User Score: 78
Chance The Rapper - The Big Day
15
basrdhim's pick

Critic Score: 67
User Score: 33
Doji Morita - Good Bye グッドバイ
Inglume's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 86
Dinosaur Jr. - Bug
Melancholic's pick

Critic Score: 84
User Score: 82
Frank Ocean - Endless
80
R E D B D E D's pick

Critic Score: 73
User Score: 82
Juice WRLD - Death Race for Love
realrealweasel's pick

Critic Score: 61
User Score: 52
12 Rods - Split Personalities
HoodieBraden's pick

Critic Score: 76
User Score: 83
Possible Space - The Truth About Last Night
SPECTRUMMAN's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 21
Aminé - Good For You
lucidfxntasy's pick

Critic Score: 69
User Score: 67
LoneMoon - Andromeda
AndreVital's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 72
The Clash - Give 'Em Enough Rope
Whynot's pick

Critic Score: 77
User Score: 80
Terrace Martin - Velvet Portraits
Allofasudden's pick

Critic Score: 76
User Score: 72
Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
90
HeyLeo's pick

Critic Score: 91
User Score: 90
Foster the People - Supermodel
Shearer's pick

Critic Score: 57
User Score: 68
City Light Mosaic - Indigo City Burning
ninakiler17’s pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 86
青葉市子 [Ichiko Aoba] - "Gift" at Sogetsu Hall
kosu’s pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 80
Natural Snow Buildings - The Winter Ray
Supertartory‘s pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 91
King Geedorah - Take Me to Your Leader
80
Doofly's pick

Critic Score: 82
User Score: 81
Wintertime - Wintertime
pizzagrande's pick

Critic Score: NR
User Score: 96
GoldLink - At What Cost
80
Rollo_P's pick

Critic Score: 68
User Score: 68
Biffy Clyro - The Vertigo of Bliss
MusicN's pick

Critic Score: 80
User Score: 77
Clipse - Hell Hath No Fury
90
MickyT's pick

Critic Score: 88
User Score: 86
1
2
Comments
Sign in to comment
8mo
why are feldman, amnesiac, mbdtf, olivia tremor control, and alice coltrane here? they're some of the most revered artists in their circles/genres
11mo
If I had to pick which one tho I’d go with chappie
11mo
Chappie, Don’t Cry & After The Disco are both the 2 most underrated albums ever
1y
some of these picks are embaressing tbh
> mbdtf
> amnesiac
god
1y
Some of these feel more overhated than underrated..
1y
lol you didn't put mine in
1y
TLCW and MBDTF are not underrated at all imo. never mind the "most underrated of all time"
1y
More personal requests would be:
christtt - no lives matter
&
The Bravery - The Bravery :)
1y
@Basic_Garci i honestly prefer Goodbye & Good Riddance but thats fair
1y
@louis™ NOOOOOOO
Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement
Likes (27)
MrA
Judakiss
Dabzilla
Docky
gopxity
Ayemdee
M3GAWATT
ThrowBackG
oh
elextranodpl
Advertisement

October 2021 Playlist
Forums