It's far from being the worst they've made, but also really far from being even remotely remarkable in their discography. Like all songs are so generic, they all try so hard to fit into this aesthetic of "folky and sweet fall music" but it doesn't work, it just comes off as the good ol' generic Weezer we all love to hate.
I'll give it this, it's really cute, but it just doesn't save it from being at points even painful to listen to. Like, listen to that opener, goodness gracious.
Let's hope "Summer" is better, or well, that any other is better than this, the concept's there, we just need Rivers and company to actually try and fight for this to work.