AOTY 2023



Best of 2023

Recent Ratings

Björk - Post
Nov 23

Pinned Review

Bob Dylan - Blood on the Tracks
500 FOLLOWERS REVIEW (big thanks to all of you guys!!!).

This one is the only Bob Dylan album I have never written a single line. There is something too big about it that keeps me always in the back of the room just listening to it without being able to put my words on it. Maybe this is a good opportunity to finally give it a try.

For many many years talking about best Dylan album was a synonym of talking about “Highway 61 Revisited” and perhaps for some bold people it was a ... read more

Recent Reviews

Iron Maiden - Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
Best Iron Maiden album.

How many bands keep improving at their seventh release? Not many

This is the case for Seventh son…here the band keep looking for the best way to incorporate new ideas to their formula without loosing their signature. And yes, they were incredible successful in this attempt.

Seventh son… is inspired by the novel Seventh Son by Orson Scott Card, which basically serves as a general idea to develop the plot for the album (check the book anyway because is ... read more

The Beatles - Now And Then
It is difficult to be super objective with The Beatles but I will do my best.
Brief summary: I love the song, I don't know if I am loving what they did with the original track.

Probably as most of you I was moved (and I am still) with John vocals. To hear him "alive" after all these years is a thing, no question about it. I clearly miss the guy and his unique sensitivity. I really love the way he approaches to this subtle atmospheres (this song reminds me to Julia or maybe Oh My ... read more

The Rolling Stones - Hackney Diamonds
A couple of notes here.

I am always worried when a classic band release a late career album. It is always a question of, are they going to just copy and paste whatever they have been doing for the last XX years? Is it going to sound soulless? Are they going to try to sound "fresh" following some sort of a new/current type of popular sound? plus the unavoidable question in this particular case, is the singer going to be capable to decently deliver? and finally the most common around ... read more

Green Day - The American Dream Is Killing Me
I can see people is kind of deciding they are back (from who knows where) and the dark times are gone. Be excited because the second coming is here... sorry but if all that crap is just based in this song, you are delusional.

This song is a copy of a copy of a copy, rhythm, drums, vocals even the lyrics is a copy of something better they have done before. yes, it sounds like American Idiot, so guess what? elections are coming and this is the perfect opportunity to resucite some old glories. I ... read more

blink-182 - ONE MORE TIME...
I am not even sure if this was disappointing or not.

I like the band, I have enjoyed way too much his early stuff to come here and say "this is the worst band ever¨, sorry I can't do that.
But the thing is that I think the real problem here is we were expecting too much from this guys. The idea was always fun and extremely simple, but even as simple as it was these guys managed themselves to create a very recognizable musical signature. Actually I must say, they invented a sound on ... read more


Hi Whynot

Thanks so much for following me. To celebrate my 200 follower milestone, I have made a special review and I was hoping you could take even just a little bit of time out of your day to read through it, it would mean so much to me if you could.
THE LIST IS OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you all for participating and all your wonderful submissions!!!!
Apologies for the wait, have a great day!!!
Honestly, what couldn't Bowie do?
The list is finally out.
Sorry for keeping you waiting! And thank you for your contrubution!
Hey there, whynot! I am almost at 100 reviews and I thought to myself, what would I review for my 100 review. What do you think? And it doesn't just have to be rock or metal. It can be anything. I will also be doing a community list on the most requested albums. Thank you!
Hey Whynot!!!
I just hit 200 followers, thank you all so much!!! To celebrate I'm doing another community list, as my last one seemed to go relatively well...

Ok, here's the scenario:

You're abducted by aliens and they're curious about the human race, and they ask you about the strange assortments of sounds we call 'music'.
What song or album would you pick to show them that encapsulates the reason why humans listen and enjoy music.

Thank you again for your contribution!!
Hello there Whynot!
Would you like to be part of my new community list? This time, the topic is "Airplane Mode": what would be, in your opinion, a perfect song to play while flying high up in the sky.
I'm looking forward to your submission! And for this occasion I will also make a playlist for Spotify and maybe YouTube as well
Whynot - the list is out! Thank you all kindly for your patience and contributions for this list. If you didn't get yours in right away, I'm still accepting submissions and edits :)
Thank you for your patience and inclusion! The list is out for public viewing. Will begin to add TWs for each song pick.
I will make sure to give it a listen! It sounds chilling and hopeless with those lyrics in mind. I appreciate your recommendation!
As many as youd like!!


What I love about this website is how some mfs who probably have never written a birthday card invitation then come here and write ¨very poor songwriting in this album¨... priceless.

Rating Distribution











Become a Donor
Donor badge, no ads + more benefits.

Recent Lists

Finally done. First two records fill the first place in my head, just depends on the day. Eighties was the most difficult decade to review... for the most it is an amazing discography.
Updated 8mo agoRanked 10
Many people consider "covers" albums as something like the laziest version of the artists. In my view , there is always something interesting to see in the way each artist interpret other ...
Updated 10mo agoRanked
Most likely the biggest musician Latin America has seen. This list is for me to keep track in his albums, find them (some of them are not easy to find), listen to them and why not? maybe put some ...
Updated 10mo ago
Member since February 8, 2020

November Playlist