Sherlock

Critic Score
User Score
Based on 145 ratings
2012 Ratings: #205
March 19, 2012 / Release Date
EP / Format
SM / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

No critic reviews have been entered.
WillNeot
76

This just proves how much ahead of their competition SHINee was at the time.

laingleys
81

such a banger song they had to do it three times

felipesunking
70

"Sherlock" é o prelúdio acertado dos anos mais vindouros do SHINee musicalmente, precedendo trabalhos grandiosos como "Odd", "1 of 1" e a trilogia "The Story of Light". Com uma proposta de introduzir conceitos e sonoridades mais maduras, as suas b-sides se voltam para sonoridades mais minimalistas e voltadas para o R&B e slow tempo, com uma única quebra com a versão coreana de 'Stranger'. Das quatro últimas faixas, ... read more

More popular reviews
heartstoyuriz
89

i might've just found one of the best b-sides that have ever graced my ears.

sherlock (clue + note): a kpop bible. the outro is my fav part. no notes otherwise.
clue: jonghyun just hootin and hollering.
note: LET ME INTRODUCE SHINEEEEEEE!!!!
alarm clock: what a fucking masterpiece of a beat. such an intimate sound. bring back 4 minute long b-sides.
the reason: wow. wow. wow. i might've cried while listening to this.
honesty: not my vibe personally.

SHERLOCK (CLUE + NOTE) // ... read more

kkolio
90

I genuinely want to be reincarnated as a child in the victorian era and when i listen to this album i will literally just explode rn

yawnjesperzzn
94

shinee's back when? miss them....

faves: Sherlock (Clue + Note), Alarm Clock, The Reason

More recent reviews
Purchasing Sherlock from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Contributions By
StarrySky, guiromeiro

April Playlist