While I think that objectively speaking this is perfect in a way as there is nothing wrong with this, nothing, everything is perfect, I can't say I don't like the silence. If there was a song that followed this that lets say was perfect, I would probably lower the rating since the silence alone ruins that song. This is perfection in art and to the ears. How can something be bad if there is nothing there, since there is no song after there is nothing there to say it is bad.
However, I rate off ... read more
The original song is better (obviously). The vocals on here sound different from the original, and it is not change that deserves a warm welcome, not to mention the production sounds worse, and I love Kendrick, but he doesn't fit on this song. While his verse was filled with bars that went hard it wasn't mixed well, and also his voice sounded different too. It lacked interest, both of their vocals. Also, Kendrick adding to the song outside of his verse like with the chorus or little adlibs he ... read more
1
Create an account to rate and review albums.
Recent Review Comments
On John Cage - 4’33”
"To add to this, put it simply pure silence is the only way for something to be objectively perfect. Nothing is perfect. Silence is nothing. But there is no real nothing because technically no noise is something. Same way with perfection there is no real perfection. But nothing is perfection, as there is nothing wrong with it. Think about it. There is nothing wrong with something that isn't there. Perfection means there is nothing wrong. While no noise one could say they don't enjoy, that isn't objective. You don't like silence well that doesn't matter. There can always be a song with lyrics that is technically objectively perfect but one can make an argument that the lyric has the tiniest bit of a mistake or that it isn't perfect because there is nothing someone can say that is objectively perfect so there cannot be music that is objectively perfect, but there is silence that can be.
As I said I rate off of subjectivity so yes objectively it is 100, but I don't enjoy it as one."
Advertisement