Halsey - Without Me
Basicahhtastelo
Jan 28, 2026
29

Why is Halsey’s catalog so highly rated? Everything I’ve heard from her sounds so generic and fake-“diva” that it makes me want to rip my fucking eye out of its socket. Her voice is awful, and the production is okay, I guess, but it doesn’t save the song. I’m being real with you guys, lol — Halsey is awful. It also doesn’t help that my family was obsessed with her, so it became extremely overplayed, and I never liked the fucking song in the first place.

Vocals: 27/100
Lyricism: 11/100 — Oh my gawd guys she said bad wooord she must be super angy or telling anything interesting at all for fucks sake
Production: 56/100

Average: 31.3

3

Comments

Nemothefishman
4mo
Idk if I’d call 60s-70s highly rated, but I do think most of the later ratings (Manic onward) are deserved.
r4j
4mo
hey, dipshit, if you listened to ALL of her albums you'd realize she doesn't even make generic pop anymore.
Basicahhtastelo
4mo
@r4j Fair enough but I everything I've heard from The Great Impersonator or whatever has been below average at best so I still don't get the hype unfortunately
Sign in to comment.
Advertisement
Rate and review albums along with the AOTY community. Create an account today.
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.

April Playlist