criticcon

Taylor Swift’s latest release is a disappointing entry in her discography, falling drastically short of the quality and depth she has delivered in the past. What was once a career defined by sharp lyricism, emotional resonance, and storytelling has now been replaced with uninspired writing and a sense of creative fatigue.

The songwriting here feels alarmingly careless lines lack depth, imagery feels forced, and the emotional weight that once made Taylor a standout is completely missing. ... read more

No words, just evermore, minus 5 because of Dorothea wbk

I wish I could rate it higher, but its a re-recording and i still prefer the og one because i like her teenage voice on this album. But i like songs like Timeless, Last Kiss, Mean, Dear John, Sparks fly, Back to December. This is my favourite album of hers, but vault tracks didn’t catch me like the standard version did. I can understand why it was in the vault for years. My favourite is still STORY OF US & HAUNTED & LAST KISS & BTD & DEAR JOHN & MEAN & ENCHANTED oh ... read more

The perfect pop album that weighs equally in writing and production. This is her best pop album, so much intention and passion can be heard from this album. You just know what a well thought album is. The vault tracks are one of the best pop songs of her career.