every song that has Lin in it is horseshit everything else is pretty okay

this is a

I obsessed with this musical for like a year, but looking back it isn't the best thing I've ever listened to
I love the vocals, and mostly every song is pretty memorable (although there are a few I just skip because they aren't very interesting)
the lyrics are really rough but I think with the mood and genre of the musical it'd be even weirder if every song had the most beautiful amazingly written lyrics
also this one is literally infinitely better than the other one and I ... read more

I just wanna see the rating higher

actually the best song I have ever listened to and there's little to no competition
I love the lyrics to this song and you don't even have to know the context in canto 9 to understand the meaning and know that this thing is a masterpiece
all that for it to be for a roland larper

would've given it a 90 but there's so many donqui larpers I have to take 1 point off

I actually don't think there's a single song I don't like in this musical and there's 23 songs

yes

actually the best album ive ever listened to

you just need to kow what's going on and then these songs hit like 500x harder (gone angel hits like a truck if you know rolands story)

really good, probably my favorite saga
I really don't know what to say other than its just a great saga all around, with WYFILWMA being one of my favorite songs of all time for obvious reasons.

this is a pretty solid saga!
I don't like six hundred strike in its intended context, but the final part might be my favorite part in the entire musical, save for would you fall in love with me again. get in the water is a really solid song for Poseidon, but ive always liked its demo version more since it makes Poseidon feel more like an actual character rather than a 1D "I want to kill odysseus" with no real personality.

definitely a weaker saga
I don't understand why legendary is rated higher than god games. god games is really good!
outside of god games, id say the saga really struggles to form its own identity outside of "Telemachus saga" and every song kind of blurs together when looking at the musical in its entirety.

really good saga! I don't get why its rated lower than underworld, id honestly rate both of them the same
story-wise this saga is probably one of the best, and song-wise this saga has some real bangers (scylla and thunder bringer definitely)

no longer you and the underworld are great
I dislike monsters lyrics greatly but its a solid song too (explanation in my full concept album review)

really solid saga, just not my favorite
I just feel like every song besides for wouldn't you like really lacks their own identity, all of them are just "that one circe song".

this is probably one of my favorite sagas, I really don't have any song I dislike here. not much else to say besides that, every song is pretty great

weakest saga by far, Polyphemus and survive might as well be the same track with how little they differentiate from one another
remember them is great though, id give it a 70 if I was in charge of rating each song independently
my goodbye is also great idk why people don't like Athena so much

I don't get the hate behind warrior of the mind, its a really solid song
rest of the saga is solid ig, just a man is great and definitely deserves the 77 it got

this album has some really high highs and some very low lows. I feel like the lyrics are the weakest part, and if there's anything id like to see adjusted in the final album that'd definitely be the first thing. there's just some long streaks of songs that really aren't that interesting, and some songs can be really repetitive and weak. there's definitely some exceptional songs in here and this musical had me captivated for months, but a lot of songs just aren't ... read more