Recently Rated

Metallica - Load
Metallica
Load
1996 • LP
75
Mar 13
Metallica - Metallica
Metallica
Metallica
1991 • LP
85
Mar 13
Metallica - Kill 'Em All
Metallica
Kill 'Em All
1983 • LP
80
Mar 12
Metallica - Master of Puppets
Metallica
Master of Puppets
1986 • LP
100
Mar 12
Lorna Shore - Immortal
Lorna Shore
Immortal
2020 • LP
80
Mar 12
Metallica - St. Anger
Metallica
St. Anger
2003 • LP
65
Mar 11
DIR EN GREY - Macabre
DIR EN GREY
Macabre
2000 • LP
100
Mar 9
Lorna Shore
Pain Remains
2022 • LP
100
Mar 9
Clairo - Sling
Clairo
Sling
2021 • LP
100
Mar 9

Recent Reviews

Metallica - Load
75

Load is an overhated album and I dont get it, alot of my favourite Metallica songs are on this album such as King Nothing, Bleeding Me, and Hero of the Day. It takes what The Black Album was doing and just does it better, the tracks are heavier and groovier than anything they've done before and the bass is especially noticeable in this album which I love. The only issue is the amount of filler in the album, alot of these songs are very forgettable and even though I just listened to the ... read more

Metallica - Metallica
85

Metallicas self titled album is largely an improvement on the flaws mentioned in And Justice For All. The Black Album innovated their sound to lean into a heavier but more radio friendly sound on tracks like Enter Sandman and Sad But True, but the band collectively also added emotion into their music which has seldom been done since Fade to Black. Songs like Nothing Else Matters and The Unforgiven are very fresh takes on their sound and convey a great deal emotion which I love, this was ... read more

Metallica - ...And Justice for All
70

And Justice For All is definitely a step down from the rest of Metallicas catalogue up until this point for two main reasons: Zero innovation and subpar mixing. This is Metallicas fourth album now and yet theyre trying to sound the exact same as how they sounded on Master of Puppets and Ride The Lightning, sure those are both benchmark albums but you should take what worked and change it up instead of just rehashing the exact same music. Every song on this album except Blackened and One sound ... read more

Metallica - Kill 'Em All
80

As a debut album meant to impress people it certainly succeeds, (to my knowledge) the riffs and instrumentation were groundbreaking for the time and it put Metallicas name on the map, allowing them to release two of the best albums of that decade. However there are two main issues with the album that arent big ones but should be mentioned anyway, and those are the mixing and Hetfields confidence in his vocals. Occasionally the mixing feels it leans too heavily into the instruments and it drowns ... read more

Metallica - Master of Puppets
100

Master of Puppets takes what Ride the Lightning did and made it better with zero drawbacks, and for that it is the formula for what thrash metal should be in my opinion, every thrash metal artist should draw inspiration from this album. There is nothing I can say about this album other than that it is quite possibly the greatest metal album to ever grace this planet Earth; there are ZERO flaws and everything you could ask for in a thrash album is here. On another note, this album is what first ... read more

About

objective perfect ≠ perfect to me myself and I

discord is .vvyke feel free to add

Around the Web

Rating Distribution

10037
 
90 - 99
 
80 - 893
 
70 - 792
 
60 - 691
 
50 - 59
 
40 - 49
 
30 - 39
 
20 - 29
 
10 - 19
 
0 - 9
 
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Pinned Lists

Before we begin, I need to clarify on what perfect means in my eyes, as theres a lot of albums here and some may think that due to the large amount of albums, the term “perfect” is watered down. ...
Everywhere at the end of timeCensus DesignatedLift Yr. Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven!Bloodborne the Old HuntersThe Mantle
Updated 6d agoRanked
Member since March 9, 2026

April Playlist