Offering

Critic Score
Based on 11 reviews
2017 Ratings: #575 / 966
User Score
Based on 226 ratings
2017 Ratings: #467
October 6, 2017 / Release Date
LP / Format
Sinderlyn / Label
Cults, Shane StonebackProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

80
Drowned in Sound

It might sound trite, but for a band long since written off as blog-buzz ephemera, it frames their return in the redemptive context it deserves, because it just so happens that Offering is also Cults’ finest work to date.

80
AllMusic

Ultimately, Offering lives up to its name -- Cults give more of themselves on these songs than ever before, and opening themselves to more possibilities pays off with some of their most exciting music.

80
God Is in the TV

With Offering, Cults have returned with a very strong set of songs, gloriously produced. Recommended!

80
Northern Transmissions
While it may feel derivative on the surface, fans will find a lot to dig into from this latest record on repeat listens.
80
Dork
Symbolising their growth from young adults who were thrust into the limelight, to, in a way, veterans; the synths are more darling, the beats more pulsating and the vocals as soothing. They’ve managed to evolve from the innocent sound of ‘Cults’ to introduce a welcome urgency.
70
Under the Radar

With its sweet, dream-pop sound, Offering is an immediately likable record that is enjoyable on first listen. Repeated plays make it more lovable as the subtle, ultra-cool textures creep into your consciousness and make for dynamic and vibrant tunes with honeyed vocals.

70
The 405

All in all, Offering is well suited to its release date, the perfect contented collection of pop vibes to kick back with as the fall readily approaches.

67
A.V. Club

They return refreshed and optimistic on the new Offering, which retains the retro pop sensibility and breathy, high-pitched vocals of Cults’ earlier work. But the expansive, echoing space that defined those first two records (its self-titled 2011 debut sounds like it was recorded in an empty high school auditorium) is filled here with layers of synthesizer sheen.

66
Pitchfork

Now that the band has mostly retired edge from their playbook, the modicum of range and intensity in Follin’s voice feels more like a shortcoming than a stylistic choice, and makes it hard to trace the emotional trajectory of Offering. Combine all of this with the fact that the lyrics are sometimes entirely unintelligible ... and the meaning of these songs fades from view, dissolving into something both undeniably catchy and impermanent.

60
The Line of Best Fit

As much as Cults’ sound has expanded on their three album discography, Offering does the bare minimum in displaying their progression as individual artists - or as a group, for that matter.

nemgax
70

haven't I given enough

ferb
73

easily EASILY their best album. More melodies and way better choruses than anything before I have finally finally enjoyed a Cults album

Host
75

One great song and 10 mediocre ones

60 --> 75
its good, tf was i on lmao 😭

More popular reviews
albumratings4u
95

Offering by Cults is a really amazing album released in 2022. I really was impressed with the production on so many songs from this album, it was my favorite aspect about it. One song that I felt had the best production was I Took Your Picture, it reminded me of a Magdalena Bay song. The most populat song on this album that also went viral on TikTok was Guided Lily, and it is also one of the best. Overall, I would highly recommend a listen to this album.

Lendarium007
90

ainda preciso escutar mais vezes, mas esse album tem uma das minhas musicas favoritas da vida (gilded Lily) e achei ele bem coeso liricamente e sonoramente, tem potencial para virar um dos meus favoritos

SayingShitOnAOT
75

Angels are taking me to heaven right now

More recent reviews
Purchasing Offering from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

June Playlist