Guitar Romantic

Critic Score
Based on 3 reviews
User Score
Based on 97 ratings
2003 Ratings: #278
April 1, 2003 / Release Date
LP / Format
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
AllMusic
There isn't a weak song here, not a single one that isn't on par with the best punk-pop. If you don't have this album and have even the slightest affinity for poppy punk rock or punky pop/rock, you are missing out on something special.
88
Pitchfork

At the end of the day, Guitar Romantic is simply a fucking awesome power-pop record that would've been just as relevant and engaging twenty-five years ago, and will undoubtedly be just as fun twenty-five years down the road. It may seem glaringly retro on the surface, but The Exploding Hearts have released an album that is, at its core, ageless.

76
Coke Machine Glow

This is the fleeting world of pop music, and it certainly follows through with an immediate thrill or two for the time being. As long as that's all I ever ask from Guitar Romantic, it'll never disappoint.

RichardsH
79

This would have just been the start

JayCrackers
83

28 minutes of Catchy and energtic power pop / garage pop punk with great use of lo-fi production to really make it in your face which works lovely with how utterly catchy some of these riffs and hooks are for just a super fun listen.

Track Review

Modern Kicks 9/10
I'm a Pretender 9.5/10
Thorns in Roses 7.5/10.
You're Black and Blue 8/10
Sleeping Aides and Razorblades 8.5/10.
Rumours in Town 8/10
Throwaway Style 8.5/10.
Boulevard Trash 8/10
Jailbird 7.5/10.
Still Crazy 8/10

Average: 8.3/10

koxtil
80

Simply put, this is some good pop punk.

Seeing what happened to them is so tragic. Something really could have spawned out of this, but it didn't. :(

More popular reviews
Purchasing Guitar Romantic from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

June Playlist